Boolean identity == True vs is True

by

If you want to determine whether a value is exactly True (not just a true-like value), is there any reason to use if foo == True rather than if foo is True?

If you want to make sure that foo really is a boolean and of value True, use the is operator.

Otherwise, if the type of foo implements its own __eq__() that returns a true-ish value when comparing to True, you might end up with an unexpected result.

As a rule of thumb, you should always use is with the built-in constants True, False and None.

Does this vary between implementations such as CPython (2.x and 3.x), Jython, PyPy, etc.?

In theory, is will be faster than == since the latter must honor types’ custom __eq__ implementations, while is can directly compare object identities (e.g., memory addresses).

I don’t know the source code of the various Python implementations by heart, but I assume that most of them can optimize that by using some internal flags for the existence of magic methods, so I suspect that you won’t notice the speed difference in practice.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why shouldn’t I use PyPy over CPython if PyPy is 6.3 times faster?
  2. Truth value of a Series is ambiguous. Use a.empty, a.bool(), a.item(), a.any() or a.all()
  3. Logical operators for Boolean indexing in Pandas
  4. Is False == 0 and True == 1 an implementation detail or is it guaranteed by the language?
  5. Why does Python code run faster in a function?
  6. Python vs Cpython
  7. Print to standard printer from Python?
  8. Python string ‘in’ operator implementation algorithm and time complexity
  9. Comparing boolean and int using isinstance
  10. Python’s in (__contains__) operator returns a bool whose value is neither True nor False
  11. Comparing previous row values in Pandas DataFrame
  12. Why does the `is` operator behave differently in a script vs the REPL?
  13. Why don’t Python sets preserve insertion order?
  14. How to generate a repeatable random number sequence?
  15. Why do ‘and’ & ‘or’ return operands in Python?
  16. Python Bool and int comparison and indexing on list with boolean values
  17. Python: False vs 0
  18. Why does “a == x or y or z” always evaluate to True? How can I compare “a” to all of those?
  19. Nested list comprehension scope
  20. Python evaluates 0 as False
  21. Getting a list of indices where pandas boolean series is True
  22. Cross-platform way to get PIDs by process name in python
  23. Filtering pandas dataframe with multiple Boolean columns
  24. Is a variable swap guaranteed to be atomic in python?
  25. What happens behind the scenes when python adds small ints? [duplicate]
  26. What are the differences between bool() and operator.truth()?
  27. Why does str.split not take keyword arguments?
  28. Python – logical evaluation order in “if” statement
  29. When will Jython support Python 3? [closed]
  30. deque.popleft() and list.pop(0). Is there performance difference?

Leave a Comment