Business Objects, Validation And Exceptions

by

You want to delve a bit in the remarkable work of Paul Stovell concerning data validation. He summed up his ideas at one time in this article. I happen to share his point of view on the matter, which I implemented in my own libraries.

Here are, in Paul’s words, the cons to throwing exceptions in the setters (based on a sample where a Name property should not be empty) :

  • There may be times where you actually need to have an empty name. For example, as the default value for a “Create an account” form.
  • If you’re relying on this to validate any data before saving, you’ll miss the cases where the data is already invalid. By that, I mean, if you load an account from the database with an empty name and don’t change it, you might not ever know it was invalid.
  • If you aren’t using data binding, you have to write a lot of code with try/catch blocks to show these errors to the user. Trying to show errors on the form as the user is filling it out becomes very difficult.
  • I don’t like throwing exceptions for non-exceptional things. A user setting the name of an account to “Supercalafragilisticexpialadocious” isn’t an exception, it’s an error. This is, of course, a personal thing.
  • It makes it very difficult to get a list of all the rules that have been broken. For example, on some websites, you’ll see validation messages such as “Name must be entered. Address must be entered. Email must be entered”. To display that, you’re going to need a lot of try/catch blocks.

And here are basic rules for an alternative solution :

  1. There is nothing wrong with having an invalid business object, so long as you don’t try to persist it.
  2. Any and all broken rules should be retrievable from the business object, so that data binding, as well as your own code, can see if there are errors and handle them appropriately.

More Related Contents:

  1. Is string check returns false
  2. How to check whether a string is a valid HTTP URL?
  3. How can I validate console input as integers?
  4. How to avoid a Win32 exception when accessing Process.MainModule.FileName in C#?
  5. Silent failures in C#, seemingly unhandled exceptions that does not crash the program
  6. How do you remove invalid hexadecimal characters from an XML-based data source prior to constructing an XmlReader or XPathDocument that uses the data?
  7. How to catch a specific SqlException error?
  8. What happens if a finally block throws an exception?
  9. Does a locked object stay locked if an exception occurs inside it?
  10. Why aren’t variables declared in “try” in scope in “catch” or “finally”?
  11. What are checked exceptions in Java/C#?
  12. Error 80040154 (Class not registered exception) when initializing VCProjectEngineObject (Microsoft.VisualStudio.VCProjectEngine.dll)
  13. Custom Validation Attributes: Comparing two properties in the same model
  14. Validate JSON against JSON Schema C#
  15. How to avoid a System.Runtime.InteropServices.COMException?
  16. Read Big TXT File, Out of Memory Exception
  17. How to prevent an exception in a background thread from terminating an application?
  18. Sequence contains no matching element
  19. How to get Exception Error Code in C#
  20. Could not load file or assembly … The parameter is incorrect
  21. Autonumber with Entity Framework
  22. More Elegant Exception Handling Than Multiple Catch Blocks? [duplicate]
  23. The parameterized query ….. expects the parameter ‘@units’, which was not supplied
  24. Reflection MethodInfo.Invoke() catch exceptions from inside the method
  25. Catch Application Exceptions in a Windows Forms Application
  26. Really simple WPF form data validation – how to?
  27. “Asynchronous operations are not allowed in this context”
  28. Asp.net mvc override OnException in base controller keeps propagating to Application_Error
  29. Could not load file or assembly ‘System.Windows.Interactivity’ [duplicate]
  30. Opposite of [compare(” “)] data annotation in .net?

Leave a Comment