Call by name vs call by value in Scala, clarification needed

by

The example you have given only uses call-by-value, so I will give a new, simpler, example that shows the difference.

First, let’s assume we have a function with a side-effect. This function prints something out and then returns an Int.

def something() = {
  println("calling something")
  1 // return value
}

Now we are going to define two function that accept Int arguments that are exactly the same except that one takes the argument in a call-by-value style (x: Int) and the other in a call-by-name style (x: => Int).

def callByValue(x: Int) = {
  println("x1=" + x)
  println("x2=" + x)
}

def callByName(x: => Int) = {
  println("x1=" + x)
  println("x2=" + x)
}

Now what happens when we call them with our side-effecting function?

scala> callByValue(something())
calling something
x1=1
x2=1

scala> callByName(something())
calling something
x1=1
calling something
x2=1

So you can see that in the call-by-value version, the side-effect of the passed-in function call (something()) only happened once. However, in the call-by-name version, the side-effect happened twice.

This is because call-by-value functions compute the passed-in expression’s value before calling the function, thus the same value is accessed every time. Instead, call-by-name functions recompute the passed-in expression’s value every time it is accessed.

More Related Contents:

  1. error in if return in Scala
  2. How to convert scala List in to Map
  3. How do I get around type erasure on Scala? Or, why can’t I get the type parameter of my collections?
  4. How to define and use a User-Defined Aggregate Function in Spark SQL?
  5. How to write to a file in Scala?
  6. Iteration over a sealed trait in Scala?
  7. Where does the “flatmap that s***” idiomatic expression in Scala come from?
  8. Caused by: java.lang.NullPointerException at org.apache.spark.sql.Dataset
  9. How to save DataFrame directly to Hive?
  10. Scala underscore – ERROR: missing parameter type for expanded function
  11. Setting up sbt to use Java 7 for compilation?
  12. About how to add a new column to an existing DataFrame with random values in Scala
  13. How to use Column.isin with list?
  14. Is there a generic way to memoize in Scala?
  15. How to compare two dataframe and print columns that are different in scala
  16. How to pattern match into an uppercase variable?
  17. Scala double definition (2 methods have the same type erasure)
  18. What is going wrong with `unionAll` of Spark `DataFrame`?
  19. Scala macros: What is the difference between typed (aka typechecked) and untyped Trees
  20. In Scala, what exactly does ‘val a: A = _’ (underscore) mean?
  21. What are all the instances of syntactic sugar in Scala?
  22. Scala: short form of pattern matching that returns Boolean
  23. ScalaTest in sbt: is there a way to run a single test without tags?
  24. How to reference external sbt project from another sbt project?
  25. How to use IntelliJ with Play Framework and Scala
  26. Missing parameter type error by calling toSet?
  27. Dynamically compiling scala class files at runtime in Scala 2.11
  28. How to vectorize DataFrame columns for ML algorithms?
  29. Getting subclasses of a sealed trait
  30. How to instantiate an instance of type represented by type parameter in Scala

Leave a Comment