Collection was modified; enumeration operation may not execute – why?

by

From the IEnumerable documentation:

An enumerator remains valid as long as the collection remains unchanged. If changes are made to the collection, such as adding, modifying, or deleting elements, the enumerator is irrecoverably invalidated and its behavior is undefined.

I believe the reasoning for this decision is that it cannot be guaranteed that all types of collections can sustain modification and still preserve an enumerator state. Consider a linked list — if you remove a node and an enumerator is currently on that node, the node reference may be its only state. And once that node is removed, the “next node” reference will be set to null, effectively invalidating the enumerator state and preventing further enumeration.

Since some collection implementations would have serious trouble with this kind of situation, it was decided to make this part of the IEnumerable interface contract. Allowing modification in some situations and not others would be horribly confusing. In addition, this would mean that existing code that might rely on modifying a collection while enumerating it would have serious problems when the collection implementation is changed. So making the behavior consistent across all enumerables is preferable.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to enumerate an enum
  2. What is the best way to modify a list in a ‘foreach’ loop?
  3. foreach vs someList.ForEach(){}
  4. Cleanest way to write retry logic?
  5. Casting interfaces for deserialization in JSON.NET
  6. How do I create 7-Zip archives with .NET?
  7. What is the use of ObservableCollection in .net?
  8. Regarding usage of Task.Start() , Task.Run() and Task.Factory.StartNew()
  9. Could not find a part of the path … bin\roslyn\csc.exe
  10. What .NET collection provides the fastest search
  11. Combining multiple Attributes to a single Attribute – Merge Attributes
  12. WebBrowser print settings
  13. How to retrieve the LoaderException property?
  14. DateTimePicker: pick both date and time
  15. Send JSON via POST in C# and Receive the JSON returned?
  16. XmlTextReader vs. XDocument
  17. Best way to check if a Data Table has a null value in it
  18. Download file with WebClient or HttpClient?
  19. Sql Bulk Copy/Insert in C#
  20. How can I Unescape and Reescape strings in .net?
  21. Interoperating between Matlab and C#
  22. How do I force full post-back from a button within an UpdatePanel?
  23. All cases covered Bresenham’s line-algorithm [closed]
  24. Is Using .NET 4.0 Tuples in my C# Code a Poor Design Decision?
  25. C# exception filter?
  26. Dynamically changing Textbox’s AutoComplete List causes AccessViolationException, any advice?
  27. how are nullable types implemented under the hood in .net?
  28. Can’t find how to use HttpContent
  29. Reflecting a private field from a base class
  30. what’s the use of string.Clone()?

Leave a Comment