Do I need to dispose of a Task?

by

While the normal rule of thumb is to always call Dispose() on all IDisposable implementations, Task and Task<T> are often one case where it’s better to let the finalizer take care of this.

The reason Task implements IDisposable is mainly due to an internal WaitHandle. This is required to allow task continuations to work properly, and only used when there is a continuation on a Task. If there is no continuation, the Task’s Dispose method has no real effect – so in this case, it’s not required.

That being said, in most cases where there is a Task continuation, it’s often very, very difficult to write your code in a way that allows you to properly call Dispose(). Using statements typically do not work with Task instances, since the Task call is typically asynchronous in nature. It’s very easy to dispose of the Task far too early, especially when using the using statement.

If, in your case, it’s relatively simple to keep a reference to the Task and call Dispose() on it correctly, I would do so. However, if this is going to cause your logic to get much more complex, I would typically pretend that Task isn’t IDisposable, and allow it to be cleaned up in the finalizer for the Task.

For more details, I’d recommend reading this thread on the MSDN forums where Stephen Toub describes why Task implements IDisposable in detail, and provides similar guidance to my suggestion above.

More Related Contents:

  1. Will the Garbage Collector call IDisposable.Dispose for me?
  2. Should we switch to use async I/O by default?
  3. Is it considered acceptable to not call Dispose() on a TPL Task object?
  4. Can I use the task parallel library in a .Net 3.5 project?
  5. Does SqlCommand.Dispose close the connection?
  6. Clear controls does not dispose them – what is the risk?
  7. How to dispose a class in .net?
  8. How to handle all unhandled exceptions when using Task Parallel Library?
  9. Where can I find a TPL dataflow version for 4.0?
  10. When should I dispose my objects in .NET?
  11. How do I get an animated gif to work in WPF?
  12. Image UriSource and Data Binding
  13. How to implement shared memory in .NET?
  14. WebAPI Multiple Put/Post parameters
  15. Log4Net: set Max backup files on RollingFileAppender with rolling Date
  16. .NET How to check if path is a file and not a directory?
  17. How to tell if a .NET application was compiled in DEBUG or RELEASE mode?
  18. .NET – Dictionary locking vs. ConcurrentDictionary
  19. What is the difference between HashSet and List?
  20. Retrieve the current view name in ASP.NET MVC?
  21. DataGridTextColumn.IsReadOnly seems to be faulty
  22. Why doesn’t Dapper dot net open and close the connection itself?
  23. Merging .net managed dlls
  24. WPF TextBox won’t fill in StackPanel
  25. What does the Microsoft.Bcl.Build NuGet package do?
  26. JSON.NET JsonConvert vs .NET JavaScriptSerializer [closed]
  27. KERNELBASE.dll Exception 0xe0434352 offset 0x000000000000a49d [duplicate]
  28. Creating temporary folders
  29. WPF slow to start on x64 in .NET Framework 4.0
  30. ‘Shadows’ vs. ‘Overrides’ in VB.NET

Leave a Comment