Should we switch to use async I/O by default?

by

Using async IO has become very easy with C# 5 but there is still a productivity cost associated with it. For example you need to sprinkle new keywords where previously none where necessary. You have to change the return type of your method.

If you decide later that a method should do IO you have to change the entire call chain to switch to async. It is a non-local change spreading to other modules.

You can’t profile async IO. Profiling tools pick up nothing. If you pause the debugger nothing is on any of the thread stacks. Nobody seems to be doing anything. That’s because an async IO does not hold a thread. It’s just a data structure (an object in the kernel).

The decision also depends on the application type. In a WinForms or WPF app I’d rather go with async because it integrates so nicely into the UI thread.

In an ASP.NET/WCF setting the main advantage is that you don’t exhaust the thread pool while you call long-running backend services. If you don’t have such a problem, and I think this is rather rare, you gain very little from async IO. In fact you loose performance by default.

In a Metro setting the decision has been made for you. Microsoft (legitimately) chose to trade developer productivity for user experience.

So it is not a clear decision. The pros and cons are both quite weak at this point. For that reason I refrain from giving an unambiguous recommendation. It depends very much on the specific case.

More Related Contents:

  1. Running multiple async tasks and waiting for them all to complete
  2. Best way in .NET to manage queue of tasks on a separate (single) thread
  3. Task sequencing and re-entracy
  4. Enforce an async method to be called once
  5. Can I use the task parallel library in a .Net 3.5 project?
  6. Why doesn’t await on Task.WhenAll throw an AggregateException?
  7. How to cancel a long-running Database operation?
  8. Executing tasks in parallel
  9. Use Task.Run() in synchronous method to avoid deadlock waiting on async method?
  10. A pattern for self-cancelling and restarting task
  11. What is the correct way to cancel an async operation that doesn’t accept a CancellationToken?
  12. How to handle all unhandled exceptions when using Task Parallel Library?
  13. Converting async/await to Task.ContinueWith
  14. Where can I find a TPL dataflow version for 4.0?
  15. How do I test an async method with NUnit (or possibly with another framework)?
  16. Do I need to dispose of a Task?
  17. Close and Dispose – which to call?
  18. Databinding an enum property to a ComboBox in WPF
  19. How can I query for null values in entity framework?
  20. Httplistener with HTTPS support
  21. How does RegexOptions.Compiled work?
  22. .NET: Is it possible to get HttpWebRequest to automatically decompress gzip’d responses?
  23. Windows or Visual Studio can’t find the latest installed .NET SDK due to bitness
  24. Calling a .net library method from vba
  25. Configuring log4net with xml file
  26. Correct way to escape characters in a DataTable Filter Expression
  27. How to see JIT-Compiled code in .NET VM (CLR)
  28. How to call managed code from unmanaged code?
  29. What happens if I remove the auto added supportedRuntime element?
  30. Task chaining (wait for the previous task to completed)

Leave a Comment