Garbage Collection should have removed object but WeakReference.IsAlive still returning true

by

Hit the same issue as you – my test was passing everywhere, except for under NCrunch (could be any other instrumentation in your case). Hm. Debugging with SOS revealed additional roots held on a call stack of a test method. My guess is that they were a result of code instrumentation that disabled any compiler optimizations, including those that correctly compute object reachability.

The cure here is quite simple – don’t ever hold strong references from a method that does GC and tests for aliveness. This can be easily achieved with a trivial helper method. The change below made your test case pass with NCrunch, where it was originally failing.

[TestMethod]
public void WeakReferenceTest2()
{
    var wRef2 = CallInItsOwnScope(() =>
    {
        var obj = new object();
        var wRef = new WeakReference(obj);

        wRef.IsAlive.Should().BeTrue(); //passes

        GC.Collect();

        wRef.IsAlive.Should().BeTrue(); //passes
        return wRef;
    });

    GC.Collect();

    wRef2.IsAlive.Should().BeFalse(); //used to fail, now passes
}

private T CallInItsOwnScope<T>(Func<T> getter)
{
    return getter();
}

More Related Contents:

  1. Does WeakReference make a good cache?
  2. Proper use of the IDisposable interface
  3. Understanding garbage collection in .NET
  4. Do event handlers stop garbage collection from occurring?
  5. When is it acceptable to call GC.Collect?
  6. Do you need to dispose of objects and set them to null?
  7. Best Practice for Forcing Garbage Collection in C#
  8. Implementing IDisposable correctly
  9. Memory Leak in C#
  10. Dispose, when is it called?
  11. .Net and Bitmap not automatically disposed by GC when there is no memory left
  12. Does garbage collector call Dispose()? [duplicate]
  13. GC.Collect()
  14. Monitoring Garbage Collector in C#
  15. How do events cause memory leaks in C# and how do Weak References help mitigate that?
  16. How can I write a unit test to determine whether an object can be garbage collected?
  17. Is correct to use GC.Collect(); GC.WaitForPendingFinalizers();?
  18. GC.Collect() and Finalize
  19. Can .NET Task instances go out of scope during run?
  20. Timer, event and garbage collection : am I missing something?
  21. When should I use GC.SuppressFinalize()?
  22. MemoryStream.Close() or MemoryStream.Dispose()
  23. Guidelines For Dispose() and Ninject
  24. Why should we call SuppressFinalize when we don’t have a destructor
  25. How does garbage collection and scoping work in C#? [duplicate]
  26. How do I get .NET to garbage collect aggressively?
  27. What’s the purpose of GC.SuppressFinalize(this) in Dispose() method?
  28. Should we use “workstation” garbage collection or “server” garbage collection?
  29. Garbage Collection not happening even when needed
  30. How much memory does a C#/.NET object use?

Leave a Comment