Contrary to the much-voted-up answer that @dlev gave, it can sometimes be very useful/needful to write a test like you’re suggesting. The public API of a class, as expressed through its interface, is the most important thing to test. That being said, I would use neither of the approaches you mentioned, but a Parameterized test instead, where the parameters are the implementations to be tested:
@RunWith(Parameterized.class)
public class InterfaceTesting {
public MyInterface myInterface;
public InterfaceTesting(MyInterface myInterface) {
this.myInterface = myInterface;
}
@Test
public final void testMyMethod_True() {
assertTrue(myInterface.myMethod(true));
}
@Test
public final void testMyMethod_False() {
assertFalse(myInterface.myMethod(false));
}
@Parameterized.Parameters
public static Collection<Object[]> instancesToTest() {
return Arrays.asList(
new Object[]{new MyClass1()},
new Object[]{new MyClass2()}
);
}
}