id()s of bound and unbound method objects — sometimes the same for different objects, sometimes different for the same object

by

Whenever you look up a method via instance.name (and in Python 2, class.name), the method object is created a-new. Python uses the descriptor protocol to wrap the function in a method object each time.

So, when you look up id(C.foo), a new method object is created, you retrieve its id (a memory address), then discard the method object again. Then you look up id(cobj.foo), a new method object created that re-uses the now freed memory address and you see the same value. The method is then, again, discarded (garbage collected as the reference count drops to 0).

Next, you stored a reference to the C.foo unbound method in a variable. Now the memory address is not freed (the reference count is 1, instead of 0), and you create a second method instance by looking up cobj.foo which has to use a new memory location. Thus you get two different values.

See the documentation for id():

Return the “identity” of an object. This is an integer (or long integer) which is guaranteed to be unique and constant for this object during its lifetime. Two objects with non-overlapping lifetimes may have the same id() value.

CPython implementation detail: This is the address of the object in memory.

Emphasis mine.

You can re-create a method using a direct reference to the function via the __dict__ attribute of the class, then calling the __get__ descriptor method:

>>> class C(object):
...     def foo(self):
...         pass
... 
>>> C.foo
<unbound method C.foo>
>>> C.__dict__['foo']
<function foo at 0x1088cc488>
>>> C.__dict__['foo'].__get__(None, C)
<unbound method C.foo>
>>> C.__dict__['foo'].__get__(C(), C)
<bound method C.foo of <__main__.C object at 0x1088d6f90>>

Note that in Python 3, the whole unbound / bound method distinction has been dropped; you get a function where before you’d get an unbound method, and a method otherwise, where a method is always bound:

>>> C.foo
<function C.foo at 0x10bc48dd0>
>>> C.foo.__get__(None, C)
<function C.foo at 0x10bc48dd0>
>>> C.foo.__get__(C(), C)
<bound method C.foo of <__main__.C object at 0x10bc65150>>

Furthermore, Python 3.7 adds a new LOAD_METHOD – CALL_METHOD opcode pair that replaces the current LOAD_ATTRIBUTE – CALL_FUNCTION opcode pair precisely to avoid creating a new method object each time. This optimisation transforms the executon path for instance.foo() from type(instance).__dict__['foo'].__get__(instance, type(instance))() with type(instance).__dict__['foo'](instance), so ‘manually’ passing in the instance directly to the function object.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why do I get a TypeError that says “takes no arguments (1 given)”? [duplicate]
  2. Difference between @staticmethod and @classmethod
  3. Calling a function of a module by using its name (a string)
  4. How to access object attribute given string corresponding to name of that attribute
  5. Spawning multiple instances of the same object concurrently in python
  6. How can I separate the functions of a class into multiple files?
  7. How do I save and restore multiple variables in python?
  8. unbound method f() must be called with fibo_ instance as first argument (got classobj instance instead)
  9. How to reload a module’s function in Python?
  10. Why is `object` an instance of `type` and `type` an instance of `object`?
  11. Python Method overriding, does signature matter?
  12. Python Class Based Decorator with parameters that can decorate a method or a function
  13. Why is the cmp parameter removed from sort/sorted in Python3.0?
  14. What does object’s __init__() method do in python? [duplicate]
  15. How to check if an object has an attribute in Python?
  16. Why is `self` in Python objects immutable?
  17. How can I create an object and add attributes to it?
  18. @classmethod vs @staticmethod in Python
  19. How do I check if an object has an attribute?
  20. How do I access Class member variables?
  21. How do I set and access attributes of a class? [duplicate]
  22. Why do ints require three times as much memory in Python?
  23. How does a Python set([]) check if two objects are equal? What methods does an object need to define to customise this?
  24. How to make a copy of a 2D array in Python? [duplicate]
  25. “Enabling” comparison for classes [duplicate]
  26. Python check instances of classes
  27. Calling one method from another within same class in Python
  28. Openpyxl check for empty cell
  29. Why is a method not identical to itself?
  30. How would I cross-reference a function generated by autodoc in Sphinx?

Leave a Comment