if x:, vs if x == True, vs if x is True

by

The following values in Python are false in the context of if and other logical contexts:

  • False
  • None
  • numeric values equal to 0, such as 0, 0.0, -0.0
  • empty strings: '' and u''
  • empty containers (such as lists, tuples and dictionaries)
  • anything that implements __bool__ (in Python3) to return False, or __nonzero__ (in Python2) to return False or 0.
  • anything that doesn’t implement __bool__ (in Python3) or __nonzero__ (in Python2), but does implement __len__ to return a value equal to 0

An object is considered “false” if any of those applies, and “true” otherwise, regardless of whether it’s actually equal to or identical with False or True

Now, if you’ve arranged that x is necessarily one of the objects True or False, then you can safely write if x. If you’ve arranged that the “trueness” of x indicates whether or not to perform the operation, regardless of type, then you can safely write if x. Where you can write that you should prefer to do so, since it’s cleaner to read.

Normally, if it is allowed for x to take the value True then you’re in one of those two cases, and so you would not write if x is True. The important thing is to correctly document the meaning of x, so that it reflects the test used in the code.

Python programmers are expected to know what’s considered true, so if you just document, “runs the function if x is true”, then that expresses what your original code does. Documenting it, “runs the function if x is True” would have a different meaning, and is less commonly used precisely because of the style rule in PEP8 that says to test for trueness rather than the specific value True.

However, if you wanted the code to behave differently in the case where x is an empty container from the case where it is None, then you would write something like if x is not None.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to test multiple variables for equality against a single value?
  2. Why does “a == x or y or z” always evaluate to True?
  3. Why does python use ‘else’ after for and while loops?
  4. What’s the scope of a variable initialized in an if statement?
  5. Better to ‘try’ something and catch the exception or test if it’s possible first to avoid an exception?
  6. Parsing boolean values with argparse
  7. What is a None value?
  8. Putting an if-elif-else statement on one line?
  9. How can I map True/False to 1/0 in a Pandas DataFrame?
  10. How to check if a string contains an element from a list in Python
  11. How to write inline if statement for print?
  12. SQLAlchemy: unexpected results when using `and` and `or`
  13. What does a semicolon do?
  14. overriding bool() for custom class [duplicate]
  15. Boolean value of objects in Python
  16. Evaluation of boolean expressions in Python
  17. Boolean identity == True vs is True
  18. Python: False vs 0
  19. Why does “a == x or y or z” always evaluate to True? How can I compare “a” to all of those?
  20. double equals vs is in python [duplicate]
  21. Comparing numbers give the wrong result in Python
  22. One line if-condition-assignment
  23. Python evaluates 0 as False
  24. Python “if X == Y and Z” syntax
  25. python tilde unary operator as negation numpy bool array
  26. Pythonic way to avoid “if x: return x” statements
  27. Python: check if an object is a sequence
  28. What is the recommended way to break a long if statement? (W504 line break after binary operator)
  29. Creating a Python list comprehension with an if and break
  30. Select elements of numpy array via boolean mask array

Leave a Comment