Inconsistency in divide-by-zero behavior between different value types

by

In a nutshell: the double type defines a value for infinity while the int type doesn’t. So in the double case, the result of the calculation is a value that you can actually express in the given type since it’s defined. In the int case, there is no value for infinity and thus no way to return an accurate result. Hence the exception.

VB.NET does things a little bit differently; integer division automatically results in a floating point value using the / operator. This is to allow developers to write, e.g., the expression 1 / 2, and have it evaluate to 0.5, which some would consider intuitive. If you want to see behavior consistent with C#, try this:

Console.WriteLine(1 \ 0)

Note the use of the integer division operator (\, not /) above. I believe you’ll get an exception (or a compile error–not sure which).

Similarly, try this:

Dim x As Object = 1 / 0
Console.WriteLine(x.GetType())

The above code will output System.Double.

As for the point about imprecision, here’s another way of looking at it. It isn’t that the double type has no value for exactly zero (it does); rather, the double type is not meant to provide mathematically exact results in the first place. (Certain values can be represented exactly, yes. But calculations give no promise of accuracy.) After all, the value of the mathematical expression 1 / 0 is not defined (last I checked). But 1 / x approaches infinity as x approaches zero. So from this perspective if we cannot represent most fractions n / m exactly anyway, it makes sense to treat the x / 0 case as approximate and give the value it approaches–again, infinity is defined, at least.

More Related Contents:

  1. VB Net Class in C# [closed]
  2. What is a NullReferenceException, and how do I fix it?
  3. Creating a DateTime in a specific Time Zone in c#
  4. Setting Objects to Null/Nothing after use in .NET
  5. Difference in months between two dates
  6. Way to have String.Replace only hit “whole words”
  7. When is a custom attribute’s constructor run?
  8. How do I determine a mapped drive’s actual path?
  9. Get File Icon used by Shell
  10. How to parse a string into a nullable int
  11. How to find overlapping controls that I added to form?
  12. What is a predicate in c#? [duplicate]
  13. Difference between Lookup() and Dictionary(Of list())
  14. Operation could destabilize the runtime?
  15. Install to same path when upgrading application
  16. Monitoring Garbage Collector in C#
  17. How can I join int[] to a character-separated string in .NET?
  18. .NET Configuration (app.config/web.config/settings.settings)
  19. How to Start a Process Unelevated
  20. Dependency Injection wcf
  21. Is .NET 4.0 Compatible with Windows XP SP2 or below? [closed]
  22. Save Settings in VB.Net or C#
  23. .NET graph library around? [closed]
  24. center MessageBox in parent form [duplicate]
  25. How to get status code from webclient?
  26. How to insert a Symbol (Pound, Euro, Copyright) into a Textbox
  27. Dynamically changing Textbox’s AutoComplete List causes AccessViolationException, any advice?
  28. As of today, what is the right way to work with COM objects? [duplicate]
  29. Get first element from a dictionary
  30. How to check if process is not responding?

Leave a Comment