Is it bad practice to use Reflection in Unit testing? [duplicate]

by

IMHO Reflection should really only be a last resort, reserved for the special case of unit testing legacy code or an API you can’t change. If you are testing your own code, the fact that you need to use Reflection means your design is not testable, so you should fix that instead of resorting to Reflection.

If you need to access private members in your unit tests, it usually means the class in question has an unsuitable interface, and/or tries to do too much. So either its interface should be revised, or some code should be extracted into a separate class, where those problematic methods / field accessors can be made public.

Note that using Reflection in general results in code which, apart from being harder to understand and maintain, is also more fragile. There are a whole set of errors which in the normal case would be detected by the compiler, but with Reflection they crop up as runtime exceptions only.

Update: as @tackline noted, this concerns only using Reflection within one’s own test code, not the internals of the testing framework. JUnit (and probably all other similar frameworks) uses reflection to identify and call your test methods – this is a justified and localized use of reflection. It would be difficult or impossible to provide the same features and convenience without using Reflection. OTOH it is completely encapsulated within the framework implementation, so it does not complicate or compromise our own testing code.

More Related Contents:

  1. Get declared fields of java.lang.reflect.Fields in jdk12
  2. Using reflection to change static final File.separatorChar for unit testing?
  3. How do I test a class that has private methods, fields or inner classes?
  4. Mocking static methods with Mockito
  5. Modify a class definition’s annotation string parameter at runtime
  6. How to write a Unit Test?
  7. Java Reflection Performance
  8. Can I obtain method parameter name using Java reflection?
  9. Assert equals between 2 Lists in Junit
  10. Get all of the Classes in the Classpath
  11. Unit testing a class with a Java 8 Clock
  12. How to convert a Java object (bean) to key-value pairs (and vice versa)?
  13. Copy all values from fields in one class to another through reflection
  14. Getting Class type from String
  15. Multiple RunWith Statements in jUnit
  16. String replacement in java, similar to a velocity template
  17. Accessing Java static final variable value through reflection
  18. How do I assert equality on two classes without an equals method?
  19. Using different classloaders for different JUnit tests?
  20. Java Reflection: Why is it so slow?
  21. Disable Java reflection for the current thread
  22. What’s the best way to get a Class object for an array type?
  23. java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError in junit
  24. how to export (JUnit) test suite as executable jar
  25. Testing @Scheduled in spring
  26. Cleanup after all junit tests
  27. How to mock RestTemplate in Java Spring?
  28. Java getMethod with subclass parameter
  29. Mocking behaviour resets after each test with PowerMock
  30. How to test methods that call System.exit()?

Leave a Comment