Is the Swing repaint() method still safe to use outside the EDT in Java 7+?

by

This is the official reference:

Swing’s Threading Policy

In general Swing is not thread safe. All Swing components and related classes, unless otherwise documented, must be accessed on the event dispatching thread.

And the repaint method does not “document otherwise”.

To doubly reassure you that you do not need to look any further than an individual method’s Javadoc for the definitive answer, see for example how a method’s thread safety was documented in Java 6 Javadoc.

Update

Apparently, more clarification is needed as to the distinction between normative specification, descriptive technical articles, and details of any specific implementation. What the Javadoc states is this: there is no guarantee that repaint is a thread-safe method. Incidentally, the often-discussed decision in Java 7 to remove the “thread-safe” designation from most of the Swing API was just that: a change in contract, not implementation.

The specific implementation of repaint in OpenJDK 7 appears to be thread-safe, a fact which has nothing to do with guarantees given by the specification. Code which relies on the thread safety of repaint or other methods is broken and is not guaranteed to behave properly on all Java implementations.

More Related Contents:

  1. SwingUtilities.invokeLater
  2. using sleep() for a single thread
  3. What does SwingUtilities.invokeLater do? [duplicate]
  4. Prevent Swing GUI locking up during a background task
  5. Center Align a rectangle in Java Frame/Panel [closed]
  6. JTextFields on top of active drawing on JPanel, threading problems
  7. Java Event-Dispatching Thread explanation
  8. Threads with Key Bindings
  9. java thread.sleep puts swing ui to sleep too
  10. Calling one JFrame from another using Timer without any buttons
  11. Update JLabel repeatedly with results of long running task
  12. Main Thread vs. UI Thread in Java
  13. Swing – Update Label
  14. Java Wait for thread to finish
  15. Is it safe to construct Swing/AWT widgets NOT on the Event Dispatch Thread?
  16. SwingWorker in Java [closed]
  17. How to Pause and Resume a Thread in Java from another Thread
  18. Refreshing GUI by another thread in java (swing)
  19. How could I add a simple delay in a Java Swing application?
  20. Swing Worker : function get()
  21. Java: Swing Libraries & Thread Safety
  22. Busy loop in other thread delays EDT processing
  23. Problems with Java’s Paint method, ridiculous refresh velocity
  24. Animations when using Gridbag Layout.
  25. Why is Swing threading model considered wrong and how should it be? [closed]
  26. JLayeredPane and painting
  27. Java getting download progress
  28. repaint() in Java [duplicate]
  29. Java Swing – running on EDT
  30. All JFrame freeze while do JavaMail

Leave a Comment