Java: Rationale of the Cloneable interface

by

Basically, it’s a broken interface. Ken Arnold and Bill Venners discussed it in Java Design Issues.

Arnold:

If I were to be God at this point, and many people are probably glad I am not, I would say deprecate Cloneable and have a Copyable, because Cloneable has problems. Besides the fact that it’s misspelled, Cloneable doesn’t contain the clone method. That means you can’t test if something is an instance of Cloneable, cast it to Cloneable, and invoke clone. You have to use reflection again, which is awful. That is only one problem, but one I’d certainly solve.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to properly override clone method?
  2. How do I copy an object in Java?
  3. How to clone ArrayList and also clone its contents?
  4. How do you make a deep copy of an object?
  5. Java: recommended solution for deep cloning/copying an instance
  6. How does Cloneable work in Java and how do I use it?
  7. Clone() vs Copy constructor- which is recommended in java [duplicate]
  8. Why is the clone() method protected in java.lang.Object?
  9. Deep copy, shallow copy, clone
  10. In Java, what is a shallow copy?
  11. clone() vs copy constructor vs factory method?
  12. Deep clone utility recommendation [closed]
  13. How do you clone a BufferedImage
  14. How to clone an InputStream?
  15. instanceof – incompatible conditional operand types
  16. Java’s L number (long) specification
  17. Does calling clone() on an array also clone its contents?
  18. How do I clone a generic List in Java?
  19. How to clone a JPA entity
  20. Copying a HashMap in Java
  21. clone(): ArrayList.clone() I thought does a shallow copy
  22. Why is Cloneable not deprecated?
  23. Clone method for Java arrays
  24. What is the use of cloneable interface in java?
  25. How does clone work under the hood?
  26. java.util.Date clone or copy to not expose internal reference
  27. Why do we use the clone() method in Java?
  28. Program that asks user how many times it wants to loop for (java)
  29. FirebaseListAdapter not pushing individual items for chat app – Firebase-Ui 3.1
  30. Is java.sql.Connection thread safe?

Leave a Comment