MinGW GCC: “Unknown conversion type character ‘h'” (snprintf)

by

Historically, MinGW has been in a bit of an odd situation, especially as far as C99 support goes. MinGW relies mostly on the msvcrt.dll runtime that’s distributed with Windows, and that runtime doesn’t support C99.

So with older versions of MinGW, you can run into problems in C99 mode when using C99-specific format specifiers. Also historically, GCC didn’t make any special accommodations for msvcrt.dll’s lack of support for C99 specifiers. So you’d get into situations where -Wformat wouldn’t warn about a format that wouldn’t work.

Things are improving on both sides – GCC has specific support for -Wformat when used with the MS runtime, such as:

  • -Wpedantic-ms-format so that GCC won’t complain about "I32" and "I64" (even though it’s documented, I still get a complaint about it being unrecognized even in 4.7.0 – maybe it’s brand new)
  • the ms_printf option to __attribute__((__format__))

On the other side, MinGW has provided its own snprintf() for a while, since MSVC’s variant, _snprintf(), behaves quite differently. However, MinGW relied for a long while on the printf() in msvcrt.dll, so C99 format specifiers for printf() didn’t work. At some point MinGW started providing it’s own version of printf() and friends so that you could get proper C99 (and GNU?) support. However, it seems that to be on the conservative side, these didn’t replace the msvcrt.dll versions initially. They have names like __mingw_printf().

It looks like at some point between 4.6.1 and 4.7.0, the MinGW headers started using the MinGW supplied versions as replacements for the msvcrt.dll function (at least if you’ve specifed C99).

However, it seems that with the newer versions, GCC and MinGW are still a little out of sync. Where as before GCC would not warn about specifiers that wouldn’t actually work on MinGW, not it complains about spcifiers that will.

You may want to try the following snipet of code to see how well your version of MinGW support "hhX":

printf("%hhX\n", 0x11223344);
__mingw_printf("%hhX\n", 0x11223344);

I’m not sure what to suggest to fix the problem you’re running into – I think that you may be able to patch the MinGW stdio.h header so that it has a __attribute__((__format__ (gnu_printf, ...))) attribute on the printf functions (they’re not there in the newer stdio.h, so GCC will use it’s default idea of what the format support is).

More Related Contents:

  1. printf and long double
  2. Adding leading underscores to assembly symbols with GCC on Win32?
  3. Embedding binary blobs using gcc mingw
  4. CreateProcess: No such file or directory
  5. printf not printing on console
  6. Why is the maximum size of an array “too large”?
  7. Yet Another MinGW “gcc: error: CreateProcess: No such file or directory”
  8. Printf long long int in C with GCC?
  9. Building a shared library using gcc on Linux and MinGW on Windows
  10. Why does printf not flush after the call unless a newline is in the format string?
  11. What is the difference between ‘asm’, ‘__asm’ and ‘__asm__’?
  12. Is gcc’s __attribute__((packed)) / #pragma pack unsafe?
  13. Where is the header file on Linux? Why can’t I find ? [duplicate]
  14. Is there a way to use gcc to convert C to MIPS?
  15. What is the use of _start() in C?
  16. Rand Implementation
  17. How to make weak linking work with GCC?
  18. Working of __asm__ __volatile__ (“” : : : “memory”)
  19. Determining sprintf buffer size – what’s the standard?
  20. gcc, strict-aliasing, and casting through a union
  21. How to compile my own glibc C standard library from source and use it?
  22. Why does this memory address %fs:0x28 ( fs[0x28] ) have a random value?
  23. How to print time difference in accuracy of milliseconds and nanoseconds from C in Linux?
  24. Strange array initialize expression?
  25. Why does GCC not warn for unreachable code?
  26. How do I link object files in C? Fails with “Undefined symbols for architecture x86_64”
  27. Array of size 0 at the end of struct [duplicate]
  28. What precisely does the %g printf specifier mean?
  29. How do I compile the asm generated by GCC?
  30. Is sprintf(buffer, “%s […]”, buffer, […]) safe?

Leave a Comment