Reason for the existence of non-short-circuit logical operators

by

Updated answer:

Apologies, I missed the word “logical” in your question even though it is there. (I’ve taken the liberty of emphasizing it a bit with an edit.)

Consider the case where you want any side-effects to always occur, regardless of whether the left-hand expression evaluates true or false. E.g., contrast:

if (foo() & bar()) {
    // Only call this if both operations returned true
}

with

if (foo() && bar()) {
    // Only call this if both operations returned true
}

Let’s assume both foo and bar have effects that we want to have happen regardless of whether foo returns true or false. In the first one above, I know that bar will always get called and have its effect. In the latter, of course, bar may or may not get called. If we didn’t have the non-short-circuit version, we’d have to use temporary variables:

boolean fooResult, barResult;
fooResult = foo();
barResult = bar();
if (fooResult && barResult) {
    // ...
}

You might argue (I probably would) that you should do that anyway, because it’s way too easy to misread if (foo() & bar()), but there we go, a pragmatic reason for having non-short-circuit versions.

Original answer:

How would you propose & (or |) be a short-circuited operator? With && and ||, it makes sense because you’re dealing with boolean conditions: They can be true or false, there are no shades of grey. But & and | deal with bits, not booleans. The result is a number. I mean, I guess & could not evaluate the right-hand side if the left-hand side were 0, and similarly | could not evaluate it if the left-hand side were all-bits-on for whatever the type was, but I don’t see much point to making the one edge case of each operator significant (as compared to the 254 or more other cases).

More Related Contents:

  1. Differences in boolean operators: & vs && and | vs ||
  2. Java logical operator short-circuiting
  3. Null Pointer Exception in You Tube Analytics API using Java IntelliJ IDEA?
  4. Random Number Algorithm – Implementation in Java
  5. How to convert fuzzy hash string to a file? [closed]
  6. Can’t add parameter ‘this’
  7. How to solve expression with /=
  8. When to use StringBuilder in Java [duplicate]
  9. Java heap terminology: young, old and permanent generations?
  10. How to get frequency from fft result?
  11. How to avoid ‘instanceof’ when implementing factory design pattern?
  12. How do I get whole and fractional parts from double in JSP/Java?
  13. SpringBoot – making jar files – No auto configuration classes found in META-INF/spring.factories
  14. How to specify the JDK version in Android Studio?
  15. Superclass reference not able to call subclass method in Java
  16. Using javafx.beans properties in model classes
  17. Android AudioRecord class – process live mic audio quickly, set up callback function
  18. How to use ConcurrentLinkedQueue?
  19. How to filter string for unwanted characters using regex?
  20. Connection Java – MySQL : Public Key Retrieval is not allowed
  21. How to write data to two java.io.OutputStream objects at once?
  22. Java thread creation overhead
  23. Static context cannot access non-static in Collectors
  24. XML Node to String in Java
  25. Why does incrementing a Java int eventually result in a negative number?
  26. Launch associated program or show “Open with” dialog from another program
  27. Java 8, how can I implement a switch statement using streams?
  28. spring data jpa @query and pageable
  29. Checking if a URL exists or not
  30. How to Compress/Decompress tar.gz files in java

Leave a Comment