Should I return EXIT_SUCCESS or 0 from main()?

by

EXIT_FAILURE, either in a return statement in main or as an argument to exit(), is the only portable way to indicate failure in a C or C++ program. exit(1) can actually signal successful termination on VMS, for example.

If you’re going to be using EXIT_FAILURE when your program fails, then you might as well use EXIT_SUCCESS when it succeeds, just for the sake of symmetry.

On the other hand, if the program never signals failure, you can use either 0 or EXIT_SUCCESS. Both are guaranteed by the standard to signal successful completion. (It’s barely possible that EXIT_SUCCESS could have a value other than 0, but it’s equal to 0 on every implementation I’ve ever heard of.)

Using 0 has the minor advantage that you don’t need #include <stdlib.h> in C, or #include <cstdlib> in C++ (if you’re using a return statement rather than calling exit()) — but for a program of any significant size you’re going to be including stdlib directly or indirectly anyway.

For that matter, in C starting with the 1999 standard, and in all versions of C++, reaching the end of main() does an implicit return 0; anyway, so you might not need to use either 0 or EXIT_SUCCESS explicitly. (But at least in C, I consider an explicit return 0; to be better style.)

(Somebody asked about OpenVMS. I haven’t used it in a long time, but as I recall odd status values generally denote success while even values denote failure. The C implementation maps 0 to 1, so that return 0; indicates successful termination. Other values are passed unchanged, so return 1; also indicates successful termination. EXIT_FAILURE would have a non-zero even value.)

More Related Contents:

  1. Why do we need to use `int main` and not `void main` in C++? [duplicate]
  2. Why does int main() {} compile?
  3. Is the copy constructor always called when returning by value in C++ [duplicate]
  4. What should main() return in C and C++?
  5. How do I execute a command and get the output of the command within C++ using POSIX?
  6. If a function returns no value, with a valid return type, is it okay to for the compiler to return garbage?
  7. Which is more efficient: Return a value vs. Pass by reference?
  8. Return a “NULL” object if search result not found
  9. Call a function before main [duplicate]
  10. Avoiding copy of objects with the “return” statement
  11. C++ return value without return statement
  12. Is main() overloaded in C++?
  13. Where are C/C++ main function’s parameters?
  14. g++ How to get warning on ignoring function return value
  15. Is an object guaranteed to be moved when it is returned?
  16. C++ Fatal Error LNK1120: 1 unresolved externals
  17. How to make a function return a pointer to a function? (C++)
  18. Can Qt signals return a value?
  19. in c++ main function is the entry point to program how i can change it to an other function?
  20. Why do we need argc while there is always a null at the end of argv?
  21. Should I return std::strings?
  22. Scope and return values in C++
  23. Can I treat a specific warning as an error?
  24. How do C++ progs get their return value, when a return is not specified in the function?
  25. Why calling main() is not allowed in C++
  26. What exactly is nullptr?
  27. Which, if any, C++ compilers do tail-recursion optimization?
  28. How should I deal with mutexes in movable types in C++?
  29. How can I sort a std::map first by value, then by key?
  30. Multiple “could not be resolved” problems using Eclipse with minGW

Leave a Comment