Use JNI instead of JNA to call native code?

by
  1. JNA does not support mapping of c++ classes, so if you’re using c++ library you will need a jni wrapper
  2. If you need a lot of memory copying. For example, you call one method which returns you a large byte buffer, you change something in it, then you need to call another method which uses this byte buffer. This would require you to copy this buffer from c to java, then copy it back from java to c. In this case jni will win in performance because you can keep and modify this buffer in c, without copying.

These are the problems I’ve encountered. Maybe there’s more. But in general performance is not that different between jna and jni, so wherever you can use JNA, use it.

EDIT

This answer seems to be quite popular. So here are some additions:

  1. If you need to map C++ or COM, there is a library by Oliver Chafic, creator of JNAerator, called BridJ. It is still a young library, but it has many interesting features:
    • Dynamic C / C++ / COM interop : call C++ methods, create C++ objects (and subclass C++ classes from Java!)
    • Straightforward type mappings with good use of generics (including much nicer model for Pointers)
    • Full JNAerator support
    • works on Windows, Linux, MacOS X, Solaris, Android
  2. As for memory copying, I believe JNA supports direct ByteBuffers, so memory copying can be avoided.

So, I still believe that wherever possible, it is better to use JNA or BridJ, and revert to jni if performance is critical, because if you need to call native functions frequently, performance hit is noticeable.

More Related Contents:

  1. Java Native Access doesn’t do C++, right?
  2. What is the native keyword in Java for?
  3. Where to find source code for java.lang native methods? [closed]
  4. Adding new paths for native libraries at runtime in Java
  5. Getting active window information in Java
  6. How can I tell if I’m running in 64-bit JVM or 32-bit JVM (from within a program)?
  7. How to import a class from default package
  8. How to bundle a native library and a JNI library inside a JAR?
  9. How to return an array from JNI to Java?
  10. What makes JNI calls slow?
  11. How to get the x and y of a program window in Java?
  12. How to obtain JNI interface pointer (JNIEnv *) for asynchronous calls
  13. Calling Win32 API method from Java
  14. Exception 0xC0000005 from JNI_CreateJavaVM (jvm.dll)
  15. What are native methods in Java and where should they be used? [duplicate]
  16. How to pass C structs back and forth to Java code in JNI?
  17. Why is System.arraycopy native in Java?
  18. In Java Swing how do you get a Win32 window handle (hwnd) reference to a window?
  19. How to call C++ from Java?
  20. java.lang.UnsatisfiedLinkError: Native Library XXX.so already loaded in another classloader
  21. passing string array from java to C with JNI
  22. Is there a Java library of Unix functions?
  23. JNI Hello World Unsatisfied Link Error
  24. JNI – How to callback from C++ or C to Java?
  25. Linking static library with JNI
  26. Unable to install rJava in R 3.0 in Ubuntu 13.04
  27. SWIG (v1.3.29) generated C++ to Java Vector class not acting properly
  28. Is it possible to find the source for a Java native method?
  29. How to use the same C++ code for Android and iOS?
  30. Java Native Interface 32 bit dll on 64 bit system

Leave a Comment