Using fscanf() vs. fgets() and sscanf()

by

There are a few behavior differences in the two approaches. If you use fgets() + sscanf(), you must enter both values on the same line, whereas fscanf() on stdin (or equivalently, scanf()) will read them off different lines if it doesn’t find the second value on the first line you entered.

But, probably the most important differences have to do with handling error cases and the mixing of line oriented input and field oriented input.

If you read a line that you’re unable to parse with sscanf() after having read it using fgets() your program can simply discard the line and move on. However, fscanf(), when it fails to convert fields, leaves all the input on the stream. So, if you failed to read the input you wanted, you’d have to go and read all the data you want to ignore yourself.

The other subtle gotcha comes in if you want to mix field oriented (ala scanf()) with line oriented (e.g. fgets()) calls in your code. When scanf() converts an int for example, it will leave behind a \n on the input stream (assuming there was one, like from pressing the enter key), which will cause a subsequent call to fgets() to return immediately with only that character in the input. This is a really common issue for new programmers.

So, while you are right that you can just use fscanf() like that, you may be able to avoid some headaches by using fgets() + sscanf().

More Related Contents:

  1. Recursive and non-recursive traversal of three degree tree
  2. why does this recursive program for factorial not work? [closed]
  3. How to convert a string to integer in C?
  4. A riddle (in C)
  5. Using sizeof with a dynamically allocated array
  6. Why aren’t my compile guards preventing multiple definition inclusions?
  7. Understanding INADDR_ANY for socket programming
  8. What is ‘forward declaration’ and the difference between ‘typedef struct X’ and ‘struct X’?
  9. What’s missing/sub-optimal in this memcpy implementation?
  10. Is ((void *) -1) a valid address?
  11. How to generate random numbers in parallel?
  12. How to get name associated with open HANDLE
  13. How to make clang compile to llvm IR
  14. Reading a string with spaces with sscanf
  15. Array increment operator in C
  16. Why we need to put space before %c? [duplicate]
  17. How to use #if inside #define in the C preprocessor?
  18. Object oriented programming in C [duplicate]
  19. Good STL-like library for C [closed]
  20. malloc(sizeof(int)) vs malloc(sizeof(int *)) vs (int *)malloc(sizeof(int))
  21. C left shift on 64 bits fail
  22. Why can’t local variable be used in GNU C basic inline asm statements?
  23. After K&R what book to use to learn programming in plain C? [closed]
  24. Simple swap function…why doesn’t this one swap?
  25. Why isn’t “k” incremented in the statement “m = ++i && ++j || ++k” when “++i&&++j” evaluates to true? [duplicate]
  26. Dynamic String Input – using scanf(“%as”)
  27. How do I measure time in C?
  28. To the power of in C? [duplicate]
  29. No defined type of a function parameter defaults to int? Am I insane?
  30. Why do i have to input EOF 3 times when using fgets?

Leave a Comment