Variable scope + eval in Clojure

by

1.:

The reason this doesn’t work is (more or less) given on the page you linked:

It is an error if there is no global var named by the symbol […]

And:

[…]

  1. A lookup is done in the current namespace to see if there is a mapping
    from the symbol to a var. If so, the
    value is the value of the binding of
    the var referred-to by the symbol.

  2. It is an error.

eval evaluates forms in an empty (null in CL-lingo) lexical environment. This means, that you cannot access lexical variable bindings from the caller’s scope. Also, binding creates new bindings for existing vars, which is why you cannot use it “by itself”, without having declared or defed the variables you try to bind. Besides, lexical variables (at least in CL, but I would be surprised if this wasn’t the case for Clojure) already ceased to exist at runtime – They are translated to addresses or values.

See also my older post about this topic.

2.:

So, you have to use dynamic variables. You can avoid the explicit def, but you still at least need to declare them (which defs var names without bindings):

user=> (declare ^:dynamic x)
#'user/x
user=> (binding [x 10] (eval '(prn x)))
10
nil

By the way: I suppose you know why you need eval, and that its use is considered evil when other solutions would be appropriate.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why exactly is eval evil?
  2. What is the difference between Early and Late Binding?
  3. How do I do bindings in ItemContainerStyle in WinRT?
  4. Angular 2 output from router-outlet
  5. Bind jQuery UI autocomplete using .live()
  6. What is the difference between a let-rebinding and a standard assignment?
  7. UITableView – Better Editing through Binding?
  8. How to create an object during runtime in .net
  9. Why should eval be avoided in Bash, and what should I use instead?
  10. Evaluate expression given as a string
  11. Indirect variable assignment in bash
  12. What is the temporal dead zone?
  13. Binding attribute causes duplicate component ID found in the view
  14. The ‘eval’ command in Bash and its typical uses
  15. Binding List to DataGridView in WinForm
  16. How to bind a List to a DataGridView control?
  17. Are “{Binding Path=.}” and “{Binding}” really equal
  18. Doing math in vb.net like Eval in javascript
  19. How can I dynamically include Perl modules without using eval?
  20. Mapping a function on the values of a map in Clojure
  21. WPF Treeview Databinding Hierarchal Data with mixed types
  22. WPF StringFormat on Label Content
  23. WPF StringFormat={0:C} showing as dollars
  24. TextBox and default Button binding does update too late
  25. Android how do I wait until a service is actually connected?
  26. WPF binding with StringFormat doesn’t work on ToolTips
  27. How many primitives does it take to build a LISP machine? Ten, seven or five?
  28. xjc: Two declarations cause a collision in the ObjectFactory class
  29. Function call in -> threading macro
  30. Why such implementation of partial in clojure.core

Leave a Comment