Visual Studio Git Source Control without Git for Windows or Github extension

by

This might be in line with the recent tweet from Edward Thomson (also on Stack Overflow):

I don’t mind @VisualStudio removing libgit2 and moving to git, they had good reasons but the “it acts different” excuse it reads like FUD.

There are good reasons for them to move to git: maintaining libgit2 in VS was a nightmare. (I know! I used to do it!)

And why pay to hack on (or around) libgit2 when they employ a Git for Windows maintainer?

He is talking here about Johannes Schindelin, who got employed by Microsoft last August 2015, and who is releasing the Git for Windows editions.

Totally makes sense for them to move.

So until recently, Visual Studio did not use a third party Git client, but now it does, with Visual Studio 15 (as commented by jessehouwing, VS 2015 doesn’t come with its own git.exe, it uses a library instead).

This is Visual Studio 15 Preview 5 (not Visual Studio 2015 which is v14.25123.xx)
See ycombinator.com:

Seems a shame the “15” team have given up on libgit2. Considering Microsoft have / are a contributor and presumably all contributing parties have the same goal (cross platform, feature parity etc) one has to wonder what’s so bad with libgit2 it’s been dropped in favour of shelling out to git.exe?

By dropping libgit2, they freed up some memory. Obviously the overall memory usage of VS and git is probably increased but VS teams are flogged until memory usage decreases because nobody will prioritize making it a 64 bit app

The OP asks:

as a matter of fact I’m using VS “15” Preview 5. So does that mean I’ll need to install Git for Windows or is it already shipped with VS 15? And if so why does it still prompt me to install it? – Jonney Shih 3 mins ago

jessehouwing answers:

A very minimal version ships with Visual Studio. But it’s not added to the path. So Visual Studio doesn’t rely on you installing it.

It’s installed here:
enter image description here

The best way to install a git client for your own command line escapades, is to install Git for Windows along side Visual Studio. If you’ve done so, you can dismiss the prompt from Visual Studio

Personally, I like to “install” Git simply by uncompressing the latest archive like: PortableGit-2.10.1-64-bit.7z.exe anywhere I want.

More Related Contents:

  1. Should I add the Visual Studio 2015 .vs folder to source control?
  2. How do I force "git pull" to overwrite local files?
  3. How can I see the changes in a Git commit?
  4. How can I undo git reset –hard HEAD~1?
  5. Unable to Git-push master to Github – ‘origin’ does not appear to be a git repository / permission denied
  6. Git cherry pick and datamodel integrity
  7. Sparse checkout in Git 1.7.0?
  8. How can I view a git log of just one user’s commits?
  9. Updates were rejected because the remote contains work that you do not have locally
  10. How to convert a normal Git repository to a bare one?
  11. Undo working copy modifications of one file in Git?
  12. How can I stop .gitignore from appearing in the list of untracked files?
  13. How do you get git to always pull from a specific branch?
  14. Undo git update-index –assume-unchanged
  15. Should “node_modules” folder be included in the git repository
  16. Remove file from git repository (history)
  17. What is git-rerere and how does it work?
  18. Trying To Understand/Determine A Basic Git Workflow
  19. Is it possible to alias a branch in Git?
  20. Git failed with a > fatal error. could not read Username for
  21. git pull –rebase lost commits after coworker’s git push –force
  22. git diff between cloned and original remote repository
  23. git: switch branch without detaching head
  24. Git merging within a line
  25. Does git ignore empty folders?
  26. Error “Updates were rejected because the remote contains work that you do not have locally”
  27. How do I remove a single file from the staging area (undo git add)?
  28. git svn workflow – feature branches and merge
  29. How to convert a Git repo to a submodule, which is nested in another (parent) Git repo?
  30. Limiting file size in git repository

Leave a Comment