what is aggregate initialization

by

First of all, to answer the main question, aggregate initialization means the use of brace-enclosed initializer lists to initialize all members of an aggregate (i.e. an array or struct [in C++, only certain types of structs count as aggregates]).

Obviously,

int ar[] = { 1 , 2 };

is safer than

int ar[2];
ar[0] = 1;
ar[1] = 2;

because the latter gives ample opportunity for typos and other errors in the indices of the individual elements to be initialized.

Looking at today’s C and C++, it’s unclear to me why the author makes a distinction between C and C++. Both languages enable aggregate initialization for arrays.

One possibility is that the author referred to old versions of the C Standard. Notably, in ANSI C (C89) an important restriction applied to the use of aggregate initialization: All initializers had to be constant expressions:

/* This is possible in C89: */
f(int i)
{ int ar[] = { 1 , 2 }; }

/* But this is not
   (because i is not a constant expression):
*/
f(int i)
{ int ar[] = { i , i+1 }; }

This is due to 3.5.7 in C89 (quoting from the draft I found here):

All the expressions in an initializer for an object that has static storage duration or in an initializer list for an object that has aggregate or union type shall be constant expressions.

This clearly limits the usefulness of aggregate initialization (and even in 1989, I believe many compilers implemented extensions to enable aggregate initialization also for non-constant expressions).

Later versions of the C Standard did not have this restriction, and the standardized versions of C++ (starting with C++98), I believe, never had any such restriction.

I can only speculate, but perhaps this is what the author had in mind?

More Related Contents:

  1. Why I am getting Error on p->count? Value should be Inserted [closed]
  2. How to properly add include directories with CMake
  3. C++ virtual function return type
  4. Nice way to append a vector to itself
  5. Can’t Mod Zero?
  6. Erasing from a std::vector while doing a for each?
  7. Is there a decent wait function in C++?
  8. Seeking and reading large files in a Linux C++ application
  9. call to pure virtual function from base class constructor
  10. Is std::vector copying the objects with a push_back?
  11. What is a static constructor?
  12. Is hash_map part of the STL?
  13. pointer to array c++
  14. Why does storing references (not pointers) in containers in C++ not work?
  15. What’s a good hash function for English words?
  16. Video Stabilization with OpenCV
  17. C++ error: undefined reference to ‘clock_gettime’ and ‘clock_settime’
  18. How to select a random element in std::set?
  19. Confusion between C++ and OpenGL matrix order (row-major vs column-major)
  20. What does an ampersand after this assignment operator mean?
  21. Does clearing a vector affect its capacity?
  22. Conversion from Derived** to Base**
  23. Qt macro keywords cause name collisions
  24. Is it possible to use signal inside a C++ class?
  25. freopen() equivalent for c++ streams
  26. A simple hello world NPAPI plugin for Google Chrome?
  27. Dependent scope and nested templates
  28. sizeof an array passed as function argument [duplicate]
  29. What is the purpose of Ref-qualified member functions ? [duplicate]
  30. What is assignment via curly braces called? and can it be controlled?

Leave a Comment