What is the reason behind Enum.hashCode()?

by

The only reason for using Object’s hashCode() and for making it final I can imagine, is to make me ask this question.

First of all, you should not rely on such mechanisms for sharing objects between JVMs. That’s simply not a supported use case. When you serialize / deserialize you should rely on your own comparison mechanisms or only “compare” the results against objects within your own JVM.

The reason for letting enums hashCode be implemented as Objects hash code (based on identity) is because, within one JVM there will only be one instance of each enum object. This is enough to ensure that such implementation makes sense and is correct.

You could argue like “Hey, String and the wrappers for the primitives (Long, Integer, …) all have well defined, deterministic, specifications of hashCode! Why doesn’t the enums have it?”, Well, to begin with, you can have several distinct string references representing the same string which means that using super.hashCode would be an error, so these classes necessarily need their own hashCode implementations. For these core classes it made sense to let them have well-defined deterministic hashCodes.

Why did they choose to solve it like this?

Well, look at the requirements of the hashCode implementation. The main concern is to make sure that each object should return a distinct hash code (unless it is equal to another object). The identity-based approach is super efficient and guarantees this, while your suggestion does not. This requirement is apparently stronger than any “convenience bonus” about easing up on serialization etc.

More Related Contents:

  1. Count number of values of a list having same hash value in java?
  2. How to convert fuzzy hash string to a file? [closed]
  3. How do I use Comparator to define a custom sort order?
  4. Java Enum definition
  5. What’s the advantage of a Java enum versus a class with public static final fields?
  6. How to call a method stored in a HashMap? (Java) [duplicate]
  7. Java enum and additional class files
  8. Using Enum values as String literals
  9. A for-loop to iterate over an enum in Java
  10. Ways to save enums in database
  11. Why in java enum is declared as Enum [duplicate]
  12. Why shouldn’t Java enum literals be able to have generic type parameters?
  13. Java Enum Methods – return opposite direction enum
  14. What is a best practice of writing hash function in java?
  15. Conveniently map between enum and int / String
  16. How to convert enum value to int?
  17. How to supply Enum value to an annotation from a Constant in Java
  18. Iterate enum values using java generics
  19. Enumerations: Why? When?
  20. Switch over type in java
  21. Java Enums and Switch Statements – the default case?
  22. Is it possible to write a generic enum converter for JPA?
  23. Persisting sha256 hash objects?
  24. Java, divide incoming work uniformly via hashing in multithreaded evnironments
  25. Java enum elements with spaces?
  26. Does the Enum#values() allocate memory on each call?
  27. Compare two hex strings in Java?
  28. Java using enum with switch statement
  29. Why Java does not allow overriding equals(Object) in an Enum?
  30. Java Enum getDeclaringClass vs getClass

Leave a Comment