When to use Try Catch blocks

by

It seems to me that this topic is very strange and confused. Could someone lights me up?

Definitely. I’m not a PHP user, but I might have a little insight after having worked with try/catch in ActionScript, Java, and JavaScript. Bear in mind though, that different languages and platforms encourage different uses for try/catch. That said…

The only times I’d recommend using try/catch is if you’re using a native language function that

  1. Can throw an error/exception
  2. Does not give you any tools to detect whether you’re about to do something stupid that would cause that error/exception. eg: In ActionScript, closing a loader that is not open will result in an error but the loader doesn’t have an isOpen property to check so you’re forced to wrap it in try/catch to silence an otherwise totally meaningless error.
  3. The error/exception really is meaningless.

Let’s take the examples you list and see how they square with that list.

I read someone saying that we should use try-catch blocks only to prevent fatal errors.

In the case of AS’s loader.close() function, this is good advice. That’s a fatal error, and all from an otherwise trivial misstep. On the other hand, virtually ALL errors in AS will bring your application to a halt. Would you then wrap them all in try/catch? Absolutely not! A “fatal error” is fatal for a reason. It means something terribly wrong has happened and for the application to continue on in a potentially “undefined” state is foolhardy. It’s better to know an error happened and then fix it rather than just let it go.

I read someone else saying that we should use it only on unexpected errors

That’s even worse. Those are presicely the errors you DON’T want to silence, because silencing them means that you’re never going to find them. Maybe you’re not swallowing them, though… maybe you’re logging them. But why would you try/catch/log/continue as though nothing happened, allowing the program to run in a potentially dangerous and unexpected condition? Just let the error kick you in the teeth and then fix it. There’s little more frustrating than trying to debug something that’s wrong in a program that someone else wrote because they wrapped everything in a try/catch block and then neglected to log.

Others simply say that try-catch blocks should be used everywhere because they can be also extended (extending the Exception class).

There’s potential merit to this if you’re the one doing the throwing, and you’re trying to alert yourself to an exceptional situation in your program… but why try/catch your own thrown error? Let it kick you in the teeth, then fix it so that you don’t need to throw the error anymore.

Finally someone says that PHP try-catch block are totally useless because they are very bad implemented. (On this i find a nice SO question about performance).

Maybe so. I can’t answer this one though.

So… this might be a bit of a religious question, and I’m certain people will disagree with me, but from my particular vantage point those are the lessons I’ve learned over the years about try/catch.

More Related Contents:

  1. Can I try/catch a warning?
  2. How to catch the fatal error: Maximum execution time of 30 seconds exceeded in PHP
  3. Performance of try-catch in php
  4. How to catch this error: “Notice: Undefined offset: 0”
  5. PHP try-catch blocks: are they able to catch invalid arg types?
  6. Best way to handle errors on a php page?
  7. How to efficiently use try…catch blocks in PHP
  8. Why is PHP printing variables used in if statement?
  9. How to access object data and display the comments
  10. How do you use variables within $_POST? [closed]
  11. How do I check if my string starts with a certain word in PHP? [closed]
  12. How to send UTF-8 email?
  13. Symfony3 ClassNotFoundException after bundle creation
  14. PHP list of specific files in a directory
  15. MySQLi count(*) always returns 1
  16. Manually parse raw multipart/form-data data with PHP
  17. Can’t access global variable inside function
  18. Add … if string is too long PHP [duplicate]
  19. Formulas to Calculate Geo Proximity
  20. Unset a column in a multidimensional array
  21. How to auto call function in php for every other function call
  22. Get all child, grandchild etc nodes under parent using php with mysql query results
  23. Laravel Migration table already exists, but I want to add new not the older
  24. Dynamic shipping fee based on custom radio buttons in Woocommerce
  25. Saving images in database mysql
  26. How to enable PHP’s openssl extension to install Composer?
  27. Why is $a + ++$a == 2?
  28. php multidimensional array get values
  29. How to assign Php variable value to Javascript variable? [duplicate]
  30. PHP – Flushing While Loop Data with Ajax

Leave a Comment