Why is $a + ++$a == 2?

by

All the answers explaining why you get 2 and not 1 are actually wrong. According to the PHP documentation, mixing + and ++ in this manner is undefined behavior, so you could get either 1 or 2. Switching to a different version of PHP may change the result you get, and it would be just as valid.

See example 1, which says: 

// mixing ++ and + produces undefined behavior
$a = 1;
echo ++$a + $a++; // may print 4 or 5

Notes:

  1. Operator precedence does not determine the order of evaluation. Operator precedence only determines that the expression $l + ++$l is parsed as $l + (++$l), but doesn’t determine if the left or right operand of the + operator is evaluated first. If the left operand is evaluated first, the result would be 0+1, and if the right operand is evaluated first, the result would be 1+1.

  2. Operator associativity also does not determine order of evaluation. That the + operator has left associativity only determines that $a+$b+$c is evaluated as ($a+$b)+$c. It does not determine in what order a single operator’s operands are evaluated.

Also relevant: On this bug report regarding another expression with undefined results, a PHP developer says: “We make no guarantee about the order of evaluation […], just as C doesn’t. Can you point to any place on the documentation where it’s stated that the first operand is evaluated first?”

More Related Contents:

  1. How to calculate the multiplicator in a sum like sum += sum*(mulu^n)
  2. ‘AND’ vs ‘&&’ as operator
  3. calculate math expression from a string using eval
  4. How to mathematically evaluate a string like “2-1” to produce “1”?
  5. How to evaluate formula passed as string in PHP?
  6. Finding n-th permutation without computing others
  7. A formula to find prime numbers in a loop
  8. Combinations, Dispositions and Permutations in PHP
  9. Formulas to Calculate Geo Proximity
  10. Understanding nested PHP ternary operator [duplicate]
  11. Calculating distance between zip codes in PHP
  12. Process mathematical equations in php
  13. How to get whole and decimal part of a number?
  14. PHP float calculation error when subtracting
  15. Changing the source php [closed]
  16. Remove a child with a specific attribute, in SimpleXML for PHP
  17. How to debug in WooCommerce 3+
  18. Trying to get property of non-object – Laravel 5
  19. PHP: exceptions vs errors?
  20. PHP Header redirect not working [duplicate]
  21. Using Mysqli bind_param with date and time columns?
  22. Setting environment variables for accessing in PHP when using Apache
  23. How do I insert multiple checkbox values into a table?
  24. Trim unicode whitespace in PHP 5.2
  25. Apache Mod Rewrite For Laravel
  26. What is normalized UTF-8 all about?
  27. Who Add “_” Single Underscore Query Parameter?
  28. How to get the newest file in a directory in php
  29. Using str_split on a UTF-8 encoded string
  30. Create Image From Url Any File Type

Leave a Comment