Which annotation should I use: @IdClass or @EmbeddedId

by

I consider that @EmbeddedId is probably more verbose because with @IdClass you cannot access the entire primary key object using any field access operator. Using the @EmbeddedId you can do like this:

@Embeddable class EmployeeId { name, dataOfBirth }
@Entity class Employee {
  @EmbeddedId EmployeeId employeeId;
  ...
}

This gives a clear notion of the fields that make the composite key because they are all aggregated in a class that is accessed trough a field access operator.

Another difference with @IdClass and @EmbeddedId is when it comes to write HQL :

With @IdClass you write:

select e.name from Employee e

and with @EmbeddedId you have to write:

select e.employeeId.name from Employee e

You have to write more text for the same query. Some may argue that this differs from a more natural language like the one promoted by IdClass. But most of the times understanding right from the query that a given field is part of the composite key is of invaluable help.

More Related Contents:

  1. Difference between FetchType LAZY and EAGER in Java Persistence API?
  2. Hibernate Annotations – Which is better, field or property access?
  3. Do I need elements in persistence.xml?
  4. Why does JPA have a @Transient annotation?
  5. How to annotate MYSQL autoincrement field with JPA annotations
  6. Setting default values for columns in JPA
  7. can someone please explain me @MapsId in hibernate?
  8. Inherited abstract class with JPA (+Hibernate)
  9. org.hibernate.MappingException: Could not determine type for: java.util.Set [duplicate]
  10. Name attribute in @Entity and @Table
  11. Setting a JPA timestamp column to be generated by the database?
  12. JPA Criteria Tutorial [closed]
  13. Why should anybody put annotations on the getters or setters when using JPA to map the classes?
  14. How to map one class to different tables using hibernate/jpa annotations
  15. Spring Boot, Spring Data JPA with multiple DataSources
  16. Is it possible to read the value of a annotation in java?
  17. Java Annotations values provided in dynamic manner
  18. Spring Boot + JPA : Column name annotation ignored
  19. How do different retention policies affect my annotations?
  20. JPA support for Java 8 new date and time API
  21. annotation to filter results of a @OneToMany association
  22. BeanNotOfRequiredTypeException due to autowired fields
  23. How to force Hibernate to return dates as java.util.Date instead of Timestamp?
  24. enable Annotation Processors option in Android Studio 2.2
  25. EclipseLink 2.7.0 and JPA API 2.2.0 – signature mismatch
  26. JPA Select latest instance for each item
  27. Spring Data + JPA with multiple datasources but only one set of Repositories
  28. java.lang.ClassNotFoundException: javax.persistence.Persistence cannot be found with JPA
  29. Can the annotation variables be determined at runtime?
  30. How to use Postgres JSONB datatype with JPA?

Leave a Comment