Why C# is not allowing non-member functions like C++

by

See this blog posting:

http://blogs.msdn.com/ericlippert/archive/2009/06/22/why-doesn-t-c-implement-top-level-methods.aspx

(…)

I am asked “why doesn’t C# implement feature X?” all the time. The answer is always the same: because no one ever designed, specified, implemented, tested, documented and shipped that feature. All six of those things are necessary to make a feature happen. All of them cost huge amounts of time, effort and money. Features are not cheap, and we try very hard to make sure that we are only shipping those features which give the best possible benefits to our users given our constrained time, effort and money budgets.

I understand that such a general answer probably does not address the specific question.

In this particular case, the clear user benefit was in the past not large enough to justify the complications to the language which would ensue. By stricting how different language entities nest inside each other we (1) restrict legal programs to be in a common, easily understood style, and (2) make it possible to define “identifier lookup” rules which are comprehensible, specifiable, implementable, testable and documentable.

By restricting method bodies to always be inside a struct or class, we make it easier to reason about the meaning of an unqualified identifier used in an invocation context; such a thing is always an invocable member of the current type (or a base type).

(…)

and this follow-up posting:

http://blogs.msdn.com/ericlippert/archive/2009/06/24/it-already-is-a-scripting-language.aspx

(…)

Like all design decisions, when we’re faced with a number of competing, compelling, valuable and noncompossible ideas, we’ve got to find a workable compromise. We don’t do that except by considering all the possibilites, which is what we’re doing in this case.

(emphasis from original text)

More Related Contents:

  1. How do ValueTypes derive from Object (ReferenceType) and still be ValueTypes?
  2. Stack capacity in C#
  3. Should functions return null or an empty object?
  4. How to call .NET methods from Excel VBA?
  5. Why cannot C# generics derive from one of the generic type parameters like they can in C++ templates? [duplicate]
  6. Static Generic Class as Dictionary
  7. Why check this != null?
  8. explicitly cast generic type parameters to any interface
  9. Initialization of instance fields vs. local variables
  10. What does System.Double[*] mean
  11. Try-catch speeding up my code?
  12. What are major differences between C# and Java?
  13. Hosting CLR in Delphi with/without JCL – example
  14. Float vs Double Performance
  15. How is GetHashCode() implemented for Int32?
  16. Why does C#/CLR not support method override co/contra-variance?
  17. .NET 4.0 and the dreaded OnUserPreferenceChanged Hang
  18. Asynchronous iterator Task
  19. Why does struct alignment depend on whether a field type is primitive or user-defined?
  20. Why only literal strings saved in the intern pool by default?
  21. Are static indexers not supported in C#? [duplicate]
  22. Unable to load SqlServerSpatial.dll
  23. What is the maximum length of a C#/CLI identifier?
  24. Boxing / Unboxing Nullable Types – Why this implementation?
  25. Simplest way to make cross-appdomain call?
  26. Get the calling function name from the called function [duplicate]
  27. Can you have multiple enum values for the same integer? [duplicate]
  28. Retrieve JIT output
  29. Where is the .NET JIT-compiled code cached?
  30. Where is the .NET JIT-compiled code cached?

Leave a Comment