Why can’t I get a duration in minutes or hours in java.time?

by

“Why was it implemented that way?”

Other answers deal with the toXxx() methods that allow the hours/minutes to be queried. I’ll try to deal with the why.

The TemporalAmount interface and get(TemporalUnit) method was added fairly late in the process. I personally was not entirely convinced that we had enough evidence of the right way to work the design in that area, but was slightly arm-twisted to add TemporalAmount. I believe that in doing so we slightly confused the API.

In hindsight, I believe that TemporalAmount contains the right methods, but I believe that get(TemporalUnit) should have had a different method name. The reason is that get(TemporalUnit) is essentially a framework-level method – it is not designed for day-today use. Unfortunately the method name get does not imply this, resulting in bugs like calling get(ChronoUnit.MINUTES) on Duration.

So, the way to think of get(TemporalUnit) is to imagine a low-level framework viewing the amount as a Map<TemporalUnit, Long> where Duration is a Map of size two with keys of SECONDS and NANOS.

In the same, way, Period is viewed from the low-level frameworks as a Map of size three – DAYS, MONTHS and YEARS (which fortunately has less chance of errors).

Overall, the best advice for application code is to ignore the method get(TemporalUnit). Use getSeconds(), getNano(), toHours() and toMinutes() instead.

Finally, one way to get “hh:mm:ss” from a Duration is to do:

LocalTime.MIDNIGHT.plus(duration).format(DateTimeFormatter.ofPattern("HH:mm:ss"))

Not pretty at all, but it does work for durations less than one day.

New to…Part methods in Java 9

JDK-8142936 issue now implemented in Java 9, adding the following methods to access each part of a Duration.

  • toDaysPart
  • toHoursPart
  • toMinutesPart
  • toSecondsPart
  • toMillisPart
  • toNanosPart

More Related Contents:

  1. How to parse/format dates with LocalDateTime? (Java 8)
  2. Convert java.util.Date to java.time.LocalDate
  3. Converting between java.time.LocalDateTime and java.util.Date
  4. JSON Java 8 LocalDateTime format in Spring Boot
  5. Calculate days between two Dates in Java 8
  6. UnsupportedTemporalTypeException when formatting Instant to String
  7. Convert java.time.LocalDate into java.util.Date type
  8. How to get milliseconds from LocalDateTime in Java 8
  9. cannot resolve symbol ‘java.time.LocalDate’ error in android studio
  10. JDK dateformatter parsing DayOfWeek in German locale, java8 vs java9
  11. Unit testing a class with a Java 8 Clock
  12. How can I create a Java 8 LocalDate from a long Epoch time in Milliseconds?
  13. Differences between Java 8 Date Time API (java.time) and Joda-Time
  14. How can I mock java.time.LocalDate.now()
  15. Why does the new Java 8 Date Time API not have nanosecond precision? [duplicate]
  16. Can’t parse String to LocalDate (Java 8)
  17. DateTimeFormatter month pattern letter “L” fails
  18. Formatting a Duration in Java 8 / jsr310
  19. How to extract epoch from LocalDate and LocalDateTime?
  20. Unable to obtain OffsetDateTime from TemporalAccessor
  21. How can I parse/format dates with LocalDateTime? (Java 8)
  22. LocalDate to java.util.Date and vice versa simplest conversion? [duplicate]
  23. How to convert LocalDate to SQL Date Java?
  24. How to set format of string for java.time.Instant using objectMapper?
  25. String to ZonedDateTime is changing format
  26. Format a date using the new date time API
  27. DateTimeFormatter Support for Single Digit Day of Month and Month of Year
  28. Java 8 LocalDate – How do I get all dates between two dates?
  29. What is the motivation for two different week-based-year definitions in JSR-310?
  30. What’s the difference between ZonedDateTime and OffsetDateTime?

Leave a Comment