Why copying stringstream is not allowed?

by

Copying of ANY stream in C++ is disabled by having made the copy constructor private.

Any means ANY, whether it is stringstream, istream, ostream,iostream or whatever.

Copying of stream is disabled because it doesn’t make sense. Its very very very important to understand what stream means, to actually understand why copying stream does not make sense. stream is not a container that you can make copy of. It doesn’t contain data.

If a list/vector/map or any container is a bucket, then stream is a hose through which data flows. Think of stream as some pipe through which you get data; a pipe – at one side is the source (sender), on the other side is the sink (receiver). That is called unidirectional stream. There’re also bidirectional streams through which data flows in both direction. So what does it make sense making a copy of such a thing? It doesn’t contain any data at all. It is through which you get data.

Now suppose for a while if making a copy of stream is allowed, and you created a copy of std::cin which is in fact input stream. Say the copied object is copy_cin. Now ask yourself : does it make sense to read data from copy_cin stream when the very same data has already been read from std::cin. No, it doesn’t make sense, because the user entered the data only once, the keyboard (or the input device) generated the electric signals only once and they flowed through all other hardwares and low-level APIs only once. How can your program read it twice or more?

Hence, creating copy is not allowed, but creating reference is allowed:

std::istream  copy_cin = std::cin; //error
std::istream & ref_cin = std::cin; //ok

Also note that you can create another instance of stream and can make it use the same underlying buffer which the old stream is currently using. See this : https://ideone.com/rijov

More Related Contents:

  1. How to test whether stringstream operator>> has parsed a bad type and skip it
  2. How do you clear a stringstream variable?
  3. Why does stringstream >> change value of target on failure?
  4. How to use stringstream to separate comma separated strings [duplicate]
  5. How do I check if a C++ string is an int?
  6. How to clear stringstream? [duplicate]
  7. stringstream, string, and char* conversion confusion
  8. How to read file content into istringstream?
  9. how copy from one stringstream object to another in C++?
  10. C++ Extract number from the middle of a string
  11. What’s the difference between istringstream, ostringstream and stringstream? / Why not use stringstream in every case?
  12. Why was std::strstream deprecated?
  13. Map C++ Sort and Insert elements by value
  14. C++ double char array deliminator [closed]
  15. What’s the correct way to use printf to print a size_t?
  16. Which iomanip manipulators are ‘sticky’?
  17. Behavior of post increment in cout [duplicate]
  18. Program only crashes as release build — how to debug?
  19. Is std::cout guaranteed to be initialized?
  20. Writing Universal memoization function in C++11
  21. How to change string into QString?
  22. Implicit conversion from char** to const char**
  23. Serializing and deserializing JSON with Boost
  24. C function pointers with C++11 lambdas
  25. Determining exception type after the exception is caught?
  26. C++, can I statically initialize a std::map at compile time?
  27. Why is a class allowed to have a static member of itself, but not a non-static member?
  28. Why should I initialize member variables in the order they’re declared in?
  29. Explicit Return Type of Lambda
  30. How to get the path of an active file explorer window in c++ winapi

Leave a Comment