Why do you have to call .items() when iterating over a dictionary in Python?

by

For every python container C, the expectation is that

for item in C:
    assert item in C

will pass just fine — wouldn’t you find it astonishing if one sense of in (the loop clause) had a completely different meaning from the other (the presence check)? I sure would! It naturally works that way for lists, sets, tuples, …

So, when C is a dictionary, if in were to yield key/value tuples in a for loop, then, by the principle of least astonishment, in would also have to take such a tuple as its left-hand operand in the containment check.

How useful would that be? Pretty useless indeed, basically making if (key, value) in C a synonym for if C.get(key) == value — which is a check I believe I may have performed, or wanted to perform, 100 times more rarely than what if k in C actually means, checking the presence of the key only and completely ignoring the value.

On the other hand, wanting to loop just on keys is quite common, e.g.:

for k in thedict:
    thedict[k] += 1

having the value as well would not help particularly:

for k, v in thedict.items():
    thedict[k] = v + 1

actually somewhat less clear and less concise. (Note that items was the original spelling of the “proper” methods to use to get key/value pairs: unfortunately that was back in the days when such accessors returned whole lists, so to support “just iterating” an alternative spelling had to be introduced, and iteritems it was — in Python 3, where backwards compatibility constraints with previous Python versions were much weakened, it became items again).

More Related Contents:

  1. Create a list of names whose height is higher than 160 – Explanation on nested dicts cycling [closed]
  2. How to avoid “RuntimeError: dictionary changed size during iteration” error?
  3. python: read json and loop dictionary
  4. How can I avoid “RuntimeError: dictionary changed size during iteration” error?
  5. Iterating through a JSON object
  6. Delete an element from a dictionary
  7. How to merge multiple dicts with same key or different key?
  8. Rename a dictionary key
  9. Modifying a Python dict while iterating over it
  10. Get the key corresponding to the minimum value within a dictionary
  11. Error: ” ‘dict’ object has no attribute ‘iteritems’ “
  12. How to convert an XML string to a dictionary?
  13. How to sum dict elements
  14. How does the key argument in python’s sorted function work?
  15. How do I loop through a list by twos? [duplicate]
  16. Convert a python dict to a string and back
  17. How can I use if/else in a dictionary comprehension?
  18. sort dict by value python [duplicate]
  19. Recursively access dict via attributes as well as index access?
  20. Is there anything faster than dict()?
  21. Remove an item from a dictionary when its key is unknown
  22. How to increment variable names/Is this a bad idea [duplicate]
  23. filter items in a python dictionary where keys contain a specific string
  24. “unpacking” a passed dictionary into the function’s name space in Python?
  25. Creating a dictionary with list of lists in Python
  26. How to detect if any element in a dictionary changes?
  27. Python Pickling Dictionary EOFError
  28. Is the order of a Python dictionary guaranteed over iterations?
  29. How can I make a list of dictionaries according to the Cartesian product of values in a source dictionary (“explode” the dictionary)?
  30. why dict objects are unhashable in python?

Leave a Comment