Why does foo = filter(…) return a , not a list? [duplicate]

by

Have a look at the python documentation for filter(function, iterable) (from here):

Construct an iterator from those elements of iterable for which function returns true.

So in order to get a list back you have to use list class:

shesaid = list(filter(greetings(), ["hello", "goodbye"]))

But this probably isn’t what you wanted, because it tries to call the result of greetings(), which is “hello”, on the values of your input list, and this won’t work. Here also the iterator type comes into play, because the results aren’t generated until you use them (for example by calling list() on it). So at first you won’t get an error, but when you try to do something with shesaid it will stop working:

>>> print(list(shesaid))
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "<stdin>", line 1, in <module>
TypeError: 'str' object is not callable

If you want to check which elements in your list are equal to “hello” you have to use something like this:

shesaid = list(filter(lambda x: x == "hello", ["hello", "goodbye"]))

(I put your function into a lambda, see Randy C’s answer for a “normal” function)

More Related Contents:

  1. If two variables point to the same object, why doesn’t reassigning one variable affect the other?
  2. Is a variable the name, the value, or the memory location?
  3. How to add numbers inside a variable? [closed]
  4. How can you dynamically create variables? [duplicate]
  5. How do I put a variable’s value inside a string?
  6. Getting the name of a variable as a string
  7. How to use a variable inside a regular expression?
  8. How do I check if a variable exists?
  9. Are Python variables pointers? Or else, what are they?
  10. Checking multiple values for a variable [duplicate]
  11. How to get the original variable name of variable passed to a function
  12. How would I access variables from one class to another?
  13. Variable assignment and modification (in python) [duplicate]
  14. How can I print variable and string on same line in Python?
  15. Assignment inside lambda expression in Python
  16. What is the naming convention in Python for variable and function?
  17. Dynamic variable in Python [duplicate]
  18. Multiple assignment semantics
  19. How do I save and restore multiple variables in python?
  20. Why isn’t assigning to an empty list (e.g. [] = “”) an error?
  21. pyodbc – How to perform a select statement using a variable for a parameter
  22. How references to variables are resolved in Python [duplicate]
  23. More elegant way of declaring multiple variables at the same time
  24. SqlAlchemy – Filtering by Relationship Attribute
  25. Efficient thresholding filter of an array with numpy
  26. Creating multiple variables [duplicate]
  27. Is it a good idea to dynamically create variables?
  28. How to share a variable between 2 threads
  29. Python NameError, variable ‘not defined’
  30. Multiple Unpacking Assignment in Python when you don’t know the sequence length

Leave a Comment