Why does IEnumerator inherit from IDisposable while the non-generic IEnumerator does not?

by

Basically it was an oversight. In C# 1.0, foreach never called Dispose 1. With C# 1.2 (introduced in VS2003 – there’s no 1.1, bizarrely) foreach began to check in the finally block whether or not the iterator implemented IDisposable – they had to do it that way, because retrospectively making IEnumerator extend IDisposable would have broken everyone’s implementation of IEnumerator. If they’d worked out that it’s useful for foreach to dispose of iterators in the first place, I’m sure IEnumerator would have extended IDisposable.

When C# 2.0 and .NET 2.0 came out, however, they had a fresh opportunity – new interface, new inheritance. It makes much more sense to have the interface extend IDisposable so that you don’t need an execution-time check in the finally block, and now the compiler knows that if the iterator is an IEnumerator<T> it can emit an unconditional call to Dispose.

EDIT: It’s incredibly useful for Dispose to be called at the end of iteration (however it ends). It means the iterator can hold on to resources – which makes it feasible for it to, say, read a file line by line. Iterator blocks generate Dispose implementations which make sure that any finally blocks relevant to the “current point of execution” of the iterator are executed when it’s disposed – so you can write normal code within the iterator and clean-up should happen appropriately.

1 Looking back at the 1.0 spec, it was already specified. I haven’t yet been able to verify this earlier statement that the 1.0 implementation didn’t call Dispose.

More Related Contents:

  1. Pass An Instantiated System.Type as a Type Parameter for a Generic Class
  2. How to get the type of T from a member of a generic class or method
  3. List or IList [closed]
  4. Check if a class is derived from a generic class
  5. Testing if object is of generic type in C#
  6. Value of type ‘T’ cannot be converted to
  7. C# Create New T()
  8. What are generics in C#? [closed]
  9. Passing dynamic object to C# method changes return type
  10. What does “T” mean in C#?
  11. How to call generic method with a given Type object? [duplicate]
  12. Shortcut for “null if object is null, or object.member if object is not null” [duplicate]
  13. Convert DataTable to generic List?
  14. Is there a reasonable approach to “default” type parameters in C# Generics?
  15. C# Generic Operators
  16. Dynamically Create a generic type for template
  17. Why can’t I assign a List to a List?
  18. Console.WriteLine and generic List
  19. In C#, how to instantiate a passed generic type inside a method?
  20. C# instantiate generic List from reflected Type [duplicate]
  21. Type must be a reference Type Error When Calling Generic Method
  22. Mocking generic methods in Moq without specifying T
  23. .NET Casting Generic List
  24. Filtering out values from a C# Generic Dictionary
  25. Casting array to IEnumerable
  26. How do generics get compiled by the JIT compiler?
  27. Why is it impossible to declare extension methods in a generic static class?
  28. Hashtable to Dictionary syncroot .
  29. Generic list of generic objects
  30. Generic Web Api controller to support any model

Leave a Comment