Why does memset take an int instead of a char?

by

memset predates (by quite a bit) the addition of function prototypes to C. Without a prototype, you can’t pass a char to a function — when/if you try, it’ll be promoted to int when you pass it, and what the function receives is an int.

It’s also worth noting that in C, (but not in C++) a character literal like 'a' does not have type char — it has type int, so what you pass will usually start out as an int anyway. Essentially the only way for it to start as a char and get promoted is if you pass a char variable.

In theory, memset could probably be modified so it receives a char instead of an int, but there’s unlikely to be any benefit, and a pretty decent possibility of breaking some old code or other. With an unknown but potentially fairly high cost, and almost no chance of any real benefit, I’d say the chances of it being changed to receive a char fall right on the line between “slim” and “none”.

Edit (responding to the comments): The CHAR_BIT least significant bits of the int are used as the value to write to the target.

More Related Contents:

  1. Using memset for integer array in C
  2. Why use bzero over memset?
  3. Why does “memset(arr, -1, sizeof(arr)/sizeof(int))” not clear an integer array to -1?
  4. Access element of array of pointer of structure
  5. pointer to string concept in c [closed]
  6. my code does not work and I don’t know why ;-;
  7. Pointer subtraction confusion
  8. Difference between a Structure and a Union
  9. Variable declaration placement in C
  10. Why does this implementation of offsetof() work?
  11. Concatenating Variable Names in C?
  12. C Program crashes when adding an extra int
  13. How to get fractions in an integer division?
  14. C99 boolean data type?
  15. Should I free memory before exit?
  16. Freaky way of allocating two-dimensional array?
  17. How to print the address of a function?
  18. C struct hack at work
  19. min and max value of data type in C
  20. how to exit a child process – _exit() vs. exit
  21. Why Ctrl-Z does not trigger EOF?
  22. Can a union be initialized in the declaration?
  23. Finding out the duplicate element in an array
  24. How to replace bits in a bitfield without affecting other bits using C
  25. why do we need cudaDeviceSynchronize(); in kernels with device-printf?
  26. How does C return a structure? [duplicate]
  27. Minimizing the amount of malloc() calls improves performance?
  28. multiple threads able to get flock at the same time
  29. How to know if a Linux system call is restartable or not?
  30. Unsigned to signed conversion in C

Leave a Comment