Why doesn’t my stderr redirection end after command finishes? And how do I fix it?

by

Here is a test script that reproduces the problem you are seeing.

@echo off
2>nul 3>nul (
  echo I want to see stream1
  1>&2 echo I don't want to see this stream2
  1>&3 echo I don't want to see this stream3
)
echo stream1 works fine
1>&2 echo stream2 is now "permanently" void. I don't see this.
1>&3 echo stream3 works fine

And here is the output

I want to see stream1
stream1 works fine
stream3 works fine

stderr (stream 2) has been disabled “permanently”, even for the parent CMD.EXE shell.

You can avoid the “permanent” aspect by doing your redirection in stages:

@echo off
2>nul (
  3>nul (
    echo I want to see stream1
    1>&2 echo I don't want to see this stream2
    1>&3 echo I don't want to see this stream3
  )
)
echo stream1 works fine
1>&2 echo stream2 works fine
1>&3 echo stream3 works fine

And here is the desired output:

I want to see stream1
stream1 works fine
stream2 works fine
stream3 works fine

I don’t really understand what is going on. But I have done some interesting experiments. Check out this thread: http://www.dostips.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=2836&start=30

Addendum

As Erbert has discovered and shared in his comment, the fix is even easier if you just switch the order of the redirection – no need to stage it.

@echo off
3>nul 2>nul (
  echo I want to see stream1
  1>&2 echo I don't want to see this stream2
  1>&3 echo I don't want to see this stream3
)
echo stream1 works fine
1>&2 echo stream2 works fine
1>&3 echo stream3 works fine

Update 2012-04-03
I believe I finally understand the mechanics of Windows CMD.EXE redirection. I have a working theory that fully accounts for all the weird behavior, including why reversing the order prevents the “permanent” redirection. It also explains Aacini’s observation that handle 3 appears to be connected to CON: (It isn’t, it is actually undefined as per Windows documentation).

The key points are:

1 – Whenever a handle (stream) is redirected, the original definition is transferred to the first available undefined handle. Successive redirections are always carried out from left to right.

2 – When the redirection is over, the original definitions are normally restored. But if there is a chain of redirections, then the restoration is only done 1 level deep. This is the source of the “permanent” redirection.

Edit 2014-12-19: Put another way, the restoration appears to be done using a queue structure (FIFO – First In First Out), when it should have been implemented as a stack (LIFO – Last In First Out).

3 – When CMD.EXE carries out the redirection, it saves the current definition in the undefined handle first, then it redirects the first handle. If the first handle is redirected to the originally undefined handle, then it is effectively redirected to its original definition! That is why echo hello 1>&3 outputs to the console.

The full theory and test cases are available in two consecutive posts at http://www.dostips.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=14612#p14612.

More Related Contents:

  1. Single line with multiple commands using Windows batch file
  2. How do I run two commands in one line in Windows CMD?
  3. Batch command date and time in file name
  4. Stop and Start a service via batch or cmd file?
  5. Create an empty file on the commandline in windows (like the linux touch command)
  6. Windows shell command to get the full path to the current directory?
  7. How do I minimize the command prompt from my bat file
  8. How can you find and replace text in a file using the Windows command-line environment?
  9. How do I get the application exit code from a Windows command line?
  10. Windows batch: echo without new line
  11. How to check if a process is running via a batch script
  12. How to echo with different colors in the Windows command line [closed]
  13. How to test if a file is a directory in a batch script?
  14. Escape percent in bat file
  15. How can I create an empty file at the command line in Windows?
  16. Capture output command CMD
  17. “rd” exits with errorlevel set to 0 on error when deletion fails, etc
  18. Why does only the first line of this Windows batch file execute but all three lines execute in a command shell?
  19. Curl not recognized as an internal or external command, operable program or batch file
  20. Why %processor_architecture% always returns x86 instead of AMD64
  21. How to echo “2” (no quotes) to a file, from a batch script?
  22. Why is the FOR /f loop in this batch script evaluating a blank line?
  23. Create a new cmd.exe window from within another cmd.exe prompt
  24. How do I get the equivalent of dirname() in a batch file?
  25. What would be the Windows batch equivalent for HTML’s input type=”password”?
  26. Windows console %DATE% Math
  27. Using echo y as an automated response to a pcp hostkey prompt
  28. How to detect if CMD is running as Administrator/has elevated privileges?
  29. Difference between %variable% and !variable! in batch file
  30. Batch file to upload .txt to FTP

Leave a Comment