Why is it impossible to override a getter-only property and add a setter? [closed]

by

I think the main reason is simply that the syntax is too explicit for this to work any other way. This code:

public override int MyProperty { get { ... } set { ... } }

is quite explicit that both the get and the set are overrides. There is no set in the base class, so the compiler complains. Just like you can’t override a method that’s not defined in the base class, you can’t override a setter either.

You might say that the compiler should guess your intention and only apply the override to the method that can be overridden (i.e. the getter in this case), but this goes against one of the C# design principles – that the compiler must not guess your intentions, because it may guess wrong without you knowing.

I think the following syntax might do nicely, but as Eric Lippert keeps saying, implementing even a minor feature like this is still a major amount of effort…

public int MyProperty
{
    override get { ... } // not valid C#
    set { ... }
}

or, for autoimplemented properties,

public int MyProperty { override get; set; } // not valid C#

More Related Contents:

  1. How to get the list of properties of a class?
  2. Set object property using reflection
  3. What are Automatic Properties in C# and what is their purpose?
  4. Should I use public properties and private fields or public fields for data?
  5. Raise an event whenever a property’s value changed?
  6. Making a generic property
  7. How to check whether an object has certain method/property?
  8. How do I automatically display all properties of a class and their values in a string? [duplicate]
  9. Is the C# compiler smart enough to optimize this code?
  10. How to access property of anonymous type in C#?
  11. Enumerating through an object’s properties (string) in C#
  12. .NET DefaultValue attribute
  13. Why we need Properties in C#
  14. Best practices: throwing exceptions from properties
  15. Overloading getter and setter causes a stack overflow in C# [duplicate]
  16. How Can I add properties to a class on runtime in C#?
  17. Checking for null before ToString()
  18. Thread Safe Properties in C#
  19. Properties.Settings.Default.Save(); -> Where is that file
  20. C# 3.0 Auto-Properties – Is it possible to add custom behaviour?
  21. Getters, setters, and properties best practices. Java vs. C#
  22. What is the best practice for using public fields?
  23. Is there a good way to convert between BitmapSource and Bitmap?
  24. DataGrid column width doesn’t auto-update
  25. Travel through pixels in BMP
  26. .NET Core vs Mono
  27. Validating file types by regular expression
  28. ASP.NET Web API and [Serializable] class
  29. Is there a tool that generates P/Invoke signatures for arbitrary unmanaged DLL?
  30. Why can’t I do foreach (var Item in DataTable.Rows)?

Leave a Comment