Why is “null” present in C# and Java?

by

Anders Hejlsberg, “C# father”, just spoke about that point in his Computerworld interview:

For example, in the type system we do not have separation between value and reference types and nullability of types. This may sound a little wonky or a little technical, but in C# reference types can be null, such as strings, but value types cannot be null. It sure would be nice to have had non-nullable reference types, so you could declare that ‘this string can never be null, and I want you compiler to check that I can never hit a null pointer here’.

50% of the bugs that people run into today, coding with C# in our platform, and the same is true of Java for that matter, are probably null reference exceptions. If we had had a stronger type system that would allow you to say that ‘this parameter may never be null, and you compiler please check that at every call, by doing static analysis of the code’. Then we could have stamped out classes of bugs.

Cyrus Najmabadi, a former software design engineer on the C# team (now working at Google) discuss on that subject on his blog: (1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th).
It seems that the biggest hindrance to the adoption of non-nullable types is that notation would disturb programmers’ habits and code base. Something like 70% of references of C# programs are likely to end-up as non-nullable ones.

If you really want to have non-nullable reference type in C# you should try to use Spec#
which is a C# extension that allow the use of “!” as a non-nullable sign.

static string AcceptNotNullObject(object! s)
{
    return s.ToString();
}

More Related Contents:

  1. What is the difference between null and System.DBNull.Value?
  2. Why is Multiple Inheritance not allowed in Java or C#?
  3. C++ performance vs. Java/C#
  4. What is the difference between Nullable.HasValue or Nullable != null?
  5. Is shifting bits faster than multiplying and dividing in Java? .NET? [closed]
  6. Why does “abcd”.StartsWith(“”) return true?
  7. DateTime “null” value
  8. How would you code an efficient Circular Buffer in Java or C#?
  9. Apostrophe (‘) in XPath query
  10. C#: Passing null to overloaded method – which method is called?
  11. Making a private method public to unit test it…good idea?
  12. Where can I find a Java to C# converter? [closed]
  13. How do I handle null or optional DLL struct parameters
  14. Difference between namespace in C# and package in Java
  15. How to read a .NET Guid into a Java UUID
  16. Why should casting be avoided? [closed]
  17. DataTable equivalent in Java [duplicate]
  18. Best way to check if a Data Table has a null value in it
  19. Check for null in foreach loop
  20. DateTime “null” / uninitialized value?
  21. AES Encryption in Java and Decryption in C#
  22. Getters and Setters are bad OO design? [duplicate]
  23. What does exclamation mark mean before invoking a method in C# 8.0? [duplicate]
  24. Is there a way to suppress warnings in C# similar to Java’s @SuppressWarnings annotation?
  25. Force base method call
  26. Basic render 3D perspective projection onto 2D screen with camera (without opengl)
  27. How to determine Windows Java installation location
  28. Encryption compatible between Android and C#
  29. Encrypt in java and Decrypt in C# For AES 256 bit
  30. How captured value in anonymous methods are implemented in .NET

Leave a Comment