Why is using assign bad?

by

Actually those two operations are quite different. The first gives you 26 different objects while the second gives you only one. The second object will be a lot easier to use in analyses. So I guess I would say you have already demonstrated the major downside of assign, namely the necessity of then needing always to use get for corralling or gathering up all the similarly named individual objects that are now “loose” in the global environment. Try imagining how you would serially do anything with those 26 separate objects. A simple lapply(foo, func) will suffice for the second strategy.

That FAQ citation really only says that using assignment and then assigning names is easier, but did not imply it was “bad”. I happen to read it as “less functional” since you are not actually returning a value that gets assigned. The effect looks to be a side-effect (and in this case the assign strategy results in 26 separate side-effects). The use of assign seems to be adopted by people that are coming from languages that have global variables as a way of avoiding picking up the “True R Way”, i.e. functional programming with data-objects. They really should be learning to use lists rather than littering their workspace with individually-named items.

There is another assignment paradigm that can be used:

 foo <- setNames(  paste0(letters,1:26),  LETTERS)

That creates a named atomic vector rather than a named list, but the access to values in the vector is still done with names given to [.

More Related Contents:

  1. How to name variables on the fly?
  2. How to assign from a function which returns more than one value?
  3. Assign multiple new variables on LHS in a single line
  4. Assign multiple objects to .GlobalEnv from within a function
  5. R: Assign variable labels of data frame columns
  6. R: what’s the proper way to overwrite a function from a package?
  7. Remove duplicated rows
  8. Looping over variables in ggplot
  9. Consecutive/Rolling sums in a vector in R
  10. What ways are there to edit a function in R?
  11. Unlist a list of dataframes
  12. R-Project no applicable method for ‘meta’ applied to an object of class “character”
  13. Rstudio rmarkdown: both portrait and landscape layout in a single PDF
  14. Passing command line arguments to R CMD BATCH
  15. R – use rbind on multiple variables with similar names
  16. Displaying a greater than or equal sign
  17. Find start and end positions/indices of runs/consecutive values
  18. R package lattice won’t plot if run using source()
  19. Modifying fonts in ggplot2
  20. How do you determine the namespace of a function?
  21. How to extract certain columns from a list of data frames
  22. How to find out which package version is loaded in R?
  23. ggplot geom_point() with colors based on specific, discrete values
  24. Moving color key in R heatmap.2 (function of gplots package)
  25. GGplot custom scale transformation with custom ticks
  26. Remove part of a string in dataframe column (R)
  27. How to remove strange characters using gsub in R? [duplicate]
  28. hclust() in R on large datasets
  29. Efficient string similarity grouping
  30. Failure to connect to odbc database in R

Leave a Comment