Why prefer Properties to public variables? [duplicate]

by

We’ve had this subject before but I can’t find anything now.

In brief: your needs might change: where there’s no sanity check now, one might be required in the future. However, if you change your public fields to properties, this breaks binary compatiblity: every client who uses your code/library would have to re-compile.

This is bad because it potentially costs a lot of money.

Using properties from the beginning avoids this problem. This even counts for code that is not part of a library. Why? Because you never know: the code (even if highly domain-specific!) might prove useful so you want to refactor it to a library. This refactoring process is obviously made much easier if you are already using properties in place of public/protected fields.

Additionally, writing public properties is easy in C# 3.0 because you can just use the auto-implemented properties, saving you quite a bit of code:

public DataType MyProperty { get; set; }

Will implement the necessary backing field and getter/setter code for you.

I will add a personal note: .NET’s behaviour in this regard is somewhat lazy. The compiler could just change public fields to properties on the fly, thus avoiding the problem. VB6 already did this for COM-exposed classes and I see absolutely no reason for VB.NET and C# not to do the same. Perhaps someone on the compiler teams (Jared?) could comment on this.

More Related Contents:

  1. C# Expressional if statements, possible expansion? [closed]
  2. All possible array initialization syntaxes
  3. What is the C# Using block and why should I use it? [duplicate]
  4. C# – Keyword usage virtual+override vs. new
  5. What are Automatic Properties in C# and what is their purpose?
  6. Why are C# 3.0 object initializer constructor parentheses optional?
  7. Why do assignment statements return a value?
  8. What does the ‘=>’ syntax in C# mean?
  9. What does the tilde before a function name mean in C#?
  10. What does “DateTime?” mean in C#?
  11. Difference between wiring events with and without “new”
  12. LINQ, Where() vs FindAll()
  13. Best way to split string into lines
  14. Using Statement with Generics: using ISet = System.Collections.Generic.ISet
  15. A textbox/richtextbox that has syntax highlighting? [C#] [closed]
  16. In c# what does ‘where T : class’ mean?
  17. What does the tilde mean in an expression? [duplicate]
  18. Why is Main method private?
  19. What’s the false operator in C# good for?
  20. C# binary literals
  21. C#: Abstract classes need to implement interfaces?
  22. What does the @ prefix do on string literals in C#
  23. C# using numbers in an enum
  24. Is this pattern matching expression equivalent to not null
  25. The name ‘str’ does not exist in the current context
  26. What’s the difference between ‘int?’ and ‘int’ in C#?
  27. Why can’t we define a variable inside a while loop?
  28. Inline property initialisation and trailing comma
  29. Merging multiple PDFs using iTextSharp in c#.net
  30. SQLite .NET performance, how to speed up things?

Leave a Comment