Why were ES5 Object methods not added to Object.prototype?

by

This is all explained very nicely in “Proposed ECMAScript 3.1 Static Object Functions: Use Cases and Rationale” document (pdf) by Allen Wirfs-Brock himself (editor of ES5 spec, and a member of TC39).

I would suggest to read all of it. It’s pretty short, easily digestible, and gives a nice glimpse of the thought process behind these ES5 additions.

But to quote relevant section (emphasis mine):

A number of alternatives API designs were considered before the
proposed API was chosen. In the course of considering alternatives we
developed a set of informal guidelines that we applied when
considering the alternatives. These guidelines are:

  • Cleanly separate the meta and application layers.
  • Try to minimize the API surface area (i.e., the number of methods and the complexity of their arguments).
  • Focus on usability in naming and parameter design.
  • Try to repeatedly apply basic elements of a design.
  • If possible, enable programmers or implementations to statically optimize uses of the API.

[…]

Here are some of the alternatives that were considered that lead to
the selected design.

The obvious initial idea, following the example of the already
existing standard method Object.prototype.propertyIsEnumerable, was to
add additional “propertyIs…” query methods on Object.prototype for
the other attributes and a parallel set of attribute changing methods.

[…]

As we considered this approach there were a number of things about it
that we didn’t like and that seemed contrary to the above API design
guidelines:

  • It merges rather than separates the meta and application layers. As methods on Object.prototype the methods would be part of the public
    interface of every application object     in a program. As such, they need
    to be understood by every developer, not just library designers.

[…]

More Related Contents:

  1. Find list of strings that matches a pattern that start with a special character « and end with a special character »
  2. Which is the fastest way to loop? [for curiosity]
  3. What is the purpose of the var keyword and when should I use it (or omit it)?
  4. Get array of object’s keys
  5. Dynamically set property of nested object
  6. What does [].forEach.call() do in JavaScript?
  7. how to stop Javascript forEach? [duplicate]
  8. Is it true that every function in JavaScript is a closure?
  9. Why is it Object.defineProperty() rather than this.defineProperty() (for objects)?
  10. Creating range in JavaScript – strange syntax
  11. Automatic semicolon insertion & return statements [duplicate]
  12. What is the difference between ‘let’ and ‘const’ ECMAScript 2015 (ES6)?
  13. Why are Objects not Iterable in JavaScript?
  14. Why do catch clauses have their own lexical environment?
  15. Extending Object.prototype JavaScript
  16. How to explain object references in ECMAScript terms?
  17. Object.keys() complexity?
  18. Getting a reference to the global object in an unknown environment in strict mode
  19. Why and how does ([![]]+[][[]])[+!+[]+[+[]]] evaluate to the letter “i”? [duplicate]
  20. Can I disable ECMAscript strict mode for specific functions?
  21. Why is delete not allowed in Javascript5 strict mode?
  22. What object javascript function is bound to (what is its “this”)?
  23. Regex only capturing last instance of capture group in match
  24. Object.defineProperty in ES5?
  25. What Internal Property In ECMAScript is defined for?
  26. gulp babel, exports is not defined
  27. How to understand JS realms
  28. Why are Octal numeric literals not allowed in strict mode (and what is the workaround?)
  29. How to get the previous URL in JavaScript?
  30. What is the point of void operator in JavaScript?

Leave a Comment