Closures behaving differently in for and foreach loops

by

In C# 5 and beyond, the foreach loop declares a separate i variable for each iteration of the loop. So each closure captures a separate variable, and you see the expected results.

In the for loop, you only have a single i variable, which is captured by all the closures, and modified as the loop progresses – so by the time you call the delegates, you see the final value of that single variable.

In C# 2, 3 and 4, the foreach loop behaved that way as well, which was basically never the desired behaviour, so it was fixed in C# 5.

You can achieve the same effect in the for loop if you introduce a new variable within the scope of the loop body:

for (int i = 3; i <= 4; i++)
{
    int copy = i;
    actions.Add(() => Console.WriteLine(copy));
}

For more details, read Eric Lippert’s blog posts, “Closing over the loop variable considered harmful” – part 1, part 2.

More Related Contents:

  1. Captured Closure (Loop Variable) in C# 5.0
  2. C# foreach loop take values from outer loop to inner loop
  3. What is the best way to organize a lot of data which contains multiple conditions?
  4. How to skip “0” from a for() statement [closed]
  5. Captured variable in a loop in C#
  6. In .NET, which loop runs faster, ‘for’ or ‘foreach’?
  7. Access to Modified Closure
  8. The foreach identifier and closures
  9. Breaking out of a nested loop
  10. Detailed Explanation of Variable Capture in Closures
  11. What are ‘closures’ in C#? [duplicate]
  12. Access to Modified Closure (2)
  13. Performance difference for control structures ‘for’ and ‘foreach’ in C#
  14. What is the difference between for and foreach?
  15. For loop not returning expected value – C# – Blazor
  16. How do closures work behind the scenes? (C#)
  17. From Eric Lippert’s blog: “don’t close over the loop variable” [duplicate]
  18. How can I loop through a List and grab each item?
  19. How can I capture the value of an outer variable inside a lambda expression?
  20. Variables in a loop
  21. for and while loop in c#
  22. How captured value in anonymous methods are implemented in .NET
  23. HTML.ActionLink method
  24. Random Gaussian Variables
  25. Default parameter for value must be a compile time constant?
  26. Why the default SynchronizationContext is not captured in a Console App?
  27. How to show a image in database in the image control of Asp.net?
  28. Why FolderBrowserDialog dialog does not scroll to selected folder?
  29. Should you access a variable within the same class via a Property?
  30. How to download FTP files with automatic resume in case of disconnect

Leave a Comment