Difference between {Binding PropertyName} and {Binding Path=PropertyName}

by

There is a significant difference here which you will run into as soon as you have a complex property path with typed parameters.

Conceptually they are equivalent as they both end up setting the Binding.Path, one via the parameterized Binding constructor, the other directly via the property. What happens internally is very different though as the Binding.Path is not just a string which in both cases would be passed on to the property, it is a PropertyPath.

When XAML is parsed, type converters are used to turn strings into the types expected by properties. So when you use Path= a PropertyPathConverter will be instantiated to parse the string and return a PropertyPath. Now here is the difference:

(In the case of the Binding constructor the Object[] will be empty)

How does this matter?

If you for example have multiple indexers in a class e.g. one that expects a string and one that expects an int and you try to cast the value to target the latter, the cast will not work:

{Binding [(sys:Int32)0]}

The PropertyPath is lacking the ITypeDescriptorContext because the public constructor is invoked so the type System.Int32 cannot be resolved from the string sys:Int32.

If you use Path= however the type converter will be used instead and the type will be resolved using the context, so this will work:

{Binding Path=[(sys:Int32)0]}

(Aren’t implementation details fun?)

More Related Contents:

  1. RelativeSource binding from a ToolTip or ContextMenu
  2. WPF Attached Property Data Binding
  3. DataTrigger where value is NOT null?
  4. Are “{Binding Path=.}” and “{Binding}” really equal
  5. WPF Binding StringFormat Short Date String
  6. How to bind a TextBlock to a resource containing formatted text?
  7. How to access a control from a ContextMenu menuitem via the visual tree?
  8. How to Extract Default Control Template In Visual Studio?
  9. Binding Visibility for DataGridColumn in WPF
  10. How to bind multiple values to a single WPF TextBlock?
  11. What is so special about Generic.xaml?
  12. Best way to use a vector image in WPF?
  13. inherit style from default style
  14. WPF: Setting the Width (and Height) as a Percentage Value
  15. How do I make WPF ListView items repeat horizontally, like a horizontal scrollbar?
  16. How to disable highlighting on listbox but keep selection?
  17. How to display a different value for dropdown list values/selected item in a WPF ComboBox?
  18. WPF: Display a bool value as “Yes” / “No”
  19. Binding WPF DataGrid to DataTable using TemplateColumns
  20. How to set MouseOver event/trigger for border in XAML?
  21. Bind an element to two sources
  22. How to make XmlnsDefinition work on the local assembly?
  23. WPF Events in ResourceDictionary for a ControlTemplate
  24. A TwoWay or OneWayToSource binding cannot work on the read-only property
  25. Binding ElementName. Does it use Visual Tree or Logical Tree
  26. WPF ComboBox without drop-down button
  27. WPF DataGrid : CanContentScroll property causing odd behavior
  28. WPF ViewModel Commands CanExecute issue
  29. WPF MenuItem.Command binding to ElementName results to System.Windows.Data Error: 4 : Cannot find source for binding with reference
  30. Can you use a Binding ValidationRule within 1 line in xaml?

Leave a Comment