Does the .NET CLR JIT compile every method, every time?

by

Note: this answer is on a “per-run” context. The code is normally JITted each time you run the program. Using ngen or .NET Native changes that story, too…

Unlike HotSpot, the CLR JIT always compiles exactly once per run. It never interprets, and it never recompiles with heavier optimisation than before based on actual usage.

This may change, of course, but it’s been that way since v1 and I don’t expect it to change any time soon.

The advantage is that it makes the JIT a lot simpler – there’s no need to consider “old” code which is already running, undo optimisations based on premises which are no longer valid etc.

One point in .NET’s favour is that most CLR languages make methods non-virtual by default, which means a lot more inlining can be done. HotSpot can inline a method until it’s first overridden at which point it undoes the optimisation (or does some clever stuff in some cases to conditionally still use the inlined code, based on actual type). With fewer virtual methods to worry about, .NET can largely ignore the pain of not being able to inline anything virtual.

EDIT: The above describes the desktop framework. The Compact Framework throws out native code when it wants to, JITting again as necessary. However, this still isn’t like HotSpots adaptive optimisation.

The micro framework doesn’t JIT at all apparently, interpreting the code instead. This makes sense for very constrained devices. (I can’t say I know much about the micro framework.)

More Related Contents:

  1. When is a method eligible to be inlined by the CLR?
  2. How to see JIT-Compiled code in .NET VM (CLR)
  3. Deciphering the .NET clr20r3 exception parameters P1..P10
  4. Why Large Object Heap and why do we care?
  5. A definitive guide to API-breaking changes in .NET
  6. LINQ on the .NET 2.0 Runtime
  7. What are the roots?
  8. How do I detect at runtime that .NET version 4.5 is currently running your code?
  9. Resolving MSB3247 – Found conflicts between different versions of the same dependent assembly
  10. How do the .NET Framework, CLR and Visual Studio version numbers relate to each other?
  11. Equivalent of Class Loaders in .NET
  12. How to call managed code from unmanaged code?
  13. Is it possible to get parameters’ values for each frame in call stack in .NET
  14. No AppDomains in .NET Core! Why?
  15. Get Current .NET CLR version at runtime?
  16. Retrieve JIT output
  17. Is the CLR a virtual machine?
  18. Where is the .NET JIT-compiled code cached?
  19. Where is the .NET JIT-compiled code cached?
  20. Using Json.NET converters to deserialize properties
  21. Strange issue with System.Net.Http 4.2.0.0 not found
  22. What is the difference between List (of T) and Collection(of T)?
  23. System.BadImageFormatException: Could not load file or assembly (from installutil.exe)
  24. instance of entity type cannot be tracked because another instance with same key value is tracked [closed]
  25. How to continue field output on a second page?
  26. How to draw a signature and save it to disc as a Bitmap?
  27. Maximum Memory a .NET process can allocate
  28. Is “Code Access Security” of any real world use?
  29. Counting bits set in a .Net BitArray Class
  30. Is the CallerMemberName attribute in 4.5 “able to be faked”?

Leave a Comment