Is reading an indeterminate value undefined behavior?

by

yes, formally an rvalue conversion of indeterminate value is UB (except for unsigned char, originally i wrote “and variants” but as i recall the formal caters to 1’s complement signed char where possibly minus 0 could be used as trap value)

i’m too lazy to do the standard paragraph lookup for you, and also to lazy to care about downvotes for that

however, in practice only a problem on (1) archaic architectures, and perhaps (2) 64-bit systems.

EDIT: oops, i now seem to recall a blog posting and associated Defect Report about formal UB for accessing indeterminate char. so perhaps i’ll have to actually check the standard, + search DRs. argh, it will have to be later then, now coffee!

EDIT2: Johannes Schaub was kind enough to provide this link to SO question where that UB for accessing char was discussed. So, that’s where I remembered it from! Thanks, Johannes.

cheers & hth.,

More Related Contents:

  1. Does initialization entail lvalue-to-rvalue conversion? Is `int x = x;` UB?
  2. Uninitialized variable behaviour in C++
  3. Why is initialization of a new variable by itself valid? [duplicate]
  4. Using newly declared variable in initialization (int x = x+1)?
  5. Fun with uninitialized variables and compiler (GCC)
  6. Why is unsigned integer overflow defined behavior but signed integer overflow isn’t?
  7. May I treat a 2D array as a contiguous 1D array?
  8. Variable initialization in C++
  9. Why do constant expressions have an exclusion for undefined behavior?
  10. How is a variable at the same address producing 2 different values? [duplicate]
  11. Why can’t simple initialize (with braces) 2D std::array? [duplicate]
  12. Why should I not try to use “this” value after “delete this”?
  13. C++ compilation bug?
  14. C++ Static member initialization (template fun inside)
  15. Why class data members can’t be initialized by direct initialization syntax?
  16. Is this infinite recursion UB?
  17. What happens to uninitialized variables? C++
  18. In C++11, does `i += ++i + 1` exhibit undefined behavior?
  19. Why are arguments which do not match the conversion specifier in printf undefined behavior?
  20. Easy way find uninitialized member variables
  21. Is pointer comparison undefined or unspecified behavior in C++?
  22. C++ Structure Initialization [duplicate]
  23. Near constant time rotate that does not violate the standards
  24. Undefined behavior causing time travel
  25. How to create std::array with initialization list without providing size directly [duplicate]
  26. What’s the difference between Radio r = Radio(“PSR”, 100.8) and Radio(“PSR”, 100.8)?
  27. Initialization difference with or without curly braces in C++
  28. Initializing an std::array of non-default-constructible elements?
  29. What is the order of evaluation in a member initializer list?
  30. C++ default initialization and value initialization: which is which, which is called when and how to reliably initialize a template-type member

Leave a Comment