Is there a way to redirect ONLY stderr to stdout (not combine the two) so it can be piped to other programs?

by

Interesting question 🙂

CMD processes redirection from left to right. You want to first redirect 2 (stderr) to &1 (stdout), then redirect 1 (stdout) to something else. At this point stderr will still be redirected to the previous definition of stdout. The pipe will still work with the old definition of stdout (which now contains stderr).

If you don’t care about stdout then you can redirect to nul

program.exe 2>&1 1>nul | find " "

If you want to capture stdout to a file then redirect to a file

program.exe 2>&1 1>yourFile | find " "

If you still want to see stdout on the console, but you only want to pipe stderr to FIND, then you can redirect 1 to con:

program.exe 2>&1 1>con: | find " "

Note that there is a subtle difference between the original definition of stdout and con:. For example, cls >con: does not clear the screen, it prints a funny character to the screen instead.

It is possible to truly swap stdout and stderr if you use a 3rd (initially unused) file handle. 1 and 3 will contain original definition of stderr, and 2 will contain original definition of stdout.

program.exe 3>&2 2>&1 1>&3 | find " "

Actually there is an additional file handle defined every time a redirection is performed. The original definition is saved in the first available unused file handle. Assume there has not been any redirection prior to issuing the above command. 3>&2 does not save the original definition of 3 because 3 was not previously defined. But 2>&1 saves the original definition of stderr in 4 (3 has already been used), and 1>&2 saves the original definition of stdout in 5.

So technically, the explicit redirection of 3 is not needed to swap stderr and stdout

program.exe 2>&1 1>&3 | find " "

2>&1 saves stderr in 3 and 2 is redirected to &1 (stdout). 1>&3 saves stdout in 4 and 1 is redirected to &3 (stderr).

But the above will only work properly if you are positive that 3 has not already been defined prior to issuing the command. It is much safer to explicitly define 3 as in my prior code example.

See Why doesn’t my stderr redirection end after command finishes? And how do I fix it? for some really wild adventures with redirection 🙂

More Related Contents:

  1. How can you find and replace text in a file using the Windows command-line environment?
  2. How do I run two commands in one line in Windows CMD?
  3. How to check if a process is running via a batch script
  4. How to echo with different colors in the Windows command line [closed]
  5. Parallel execution of shell processes
  6. How to run a PowerShell script without displaying a window?
  7. Escape percent in bat file
  8. Windows Batch File Looping Through Directories to Process Files?
  9. Secure FTP using Windows batch script
  10. Capture output command CMD
  11. Why does ECHO command print some extra trailing space into the file?
  12. How to create batch file in Windows using “start” with a path and command with spaces
  13. “rd” exits with errorlevel set to 0 on error when deletion fails, etc
  14. Curl not recognized as an internal or external command, operable program or batch file
  15. Why %processor_architecture% always returns x86 instead of AMD64
  16. Why is the FOR /f loop in this batch script evaluating a blank line?
  17. How to check if a directory exists in %PATH%
  18. How do I make a log of all ECHO commands in a BATCH file?
  19. How do I minimize the command prompt from my bat file
  20. batch file Copy files with certain extensions from multiple directories into one directory
  21. Path prefixes \??\ and \\?\
  22. How to get last modified date on Windows command line for a set of files?
  23. Windows console %DATE% Math
  24. How to append a date in batch files
  25. How can I source variables from a .bat file into a PowerShell script?
  26. Windows Batch file to echo a specific line number
  27. Batch create folders based on part of file name and move files into that folder
  28. How to expand a CMD shell variable twice (recursively)
  29. Split %date% in a batch file regardless of Regional Settings
  30. Global NPM package installed but command not found

Leave a Comment