Performance of static methods vs. functions

by

Apparently this point has been fixed in later versions of PHP (5.5.12).

I ran the OP’s code (with empty methods), and I get these results :

Static Time:   1.0153820514679 ms
Object Time:   1.100515127182 ms

Edit: Eight months and some releases later…

It’s interesting to see how Zend and the community are working hard on PHP’s performance.

🐘 PHP 5.6

Here is the same benchmark with PHP 5.6.9 (ZE 2.6) :

Static Time:   0.97488021850586 ms
Object Time:   1.0362110137939 ms
Function Time: 0.96977496147156 ms

For one run, “object time” was even faster than static time, so now they are very close. Better, we can see that objects are almost fast as functions!

🐘 PHP 7.0

I’ve also compiled PHP 7.0 alpha 1 (ZE 3.0) and it is amazing to see how a fast language like PHP (Compared to other dynamic languages as you can see here or here) can be optimized again and again:

Static Time:   0.33447790145874 ms
Object Time:   0.30291485786438 ms
Function Time: 0.2329089641571 ms

With PHP7, basic functions have been greatly optimized, and “static time” is again slower than “instance/object time”.

Edit, October 2015 one year later : PHP 7.0 RC5. Now, “static time” is faster. An important thing to note: scalar type hinting (new feature in PHP7) brings a significant overhead, it’s about 16% slower (type hinting does not make your code 16% slower, it’s that slower when you code is only composed of function calls 😉 In real life applications, this is negligible). Such an overhead could seem illogic, but it’s less surprizing when you know that dynamic typing is at the core of PHP. Contrarily to other more-static languages, type hinting in PHP means more checks for the Zend Engine, and not less as some of us could expect. In the future, we will probably get more runtime optimizations on this point (exactly like HHVM’s runtime code analyses and JiT approach). Do not forget that PHP7 is young, and all the cleanup that has been done for this release permits great enhancements in the future, in features and performance.

🐘 HHVM

A test against HHVM 3.7.1 still shows that HHVM easily wins on that type of benchmarks, here you can see the benefits of a JiT compilation (JiT is a “planned” feature for future versions of PHP, we’ll probably get it in the 7.x or 8.x branches. Zend had created a PoC, as an OpCache extension):

Static Time:   0.070882797241211 ms
Object Time:   0.23940300941467 ms
Function Time: 0.06760311126709 ms

For HHVM, functions and static methods have a very similar timing, this could let us think that, internally, those are almost the same things (after all, a static method is very similar to a namespaced function). The instance timing is “catastrophic” compared to the others. This shows how HHVM and ZE are very different engines.

Conclusion?

There’s no guarantee that one of these practices (static/instance) will stay the faster, forever. Use what seems the best in terms of software design and keep a coherent code into an existing application.

If you have the choice, and/or if you’re writing a library, etc, then maybe you could use instance methods, it’s more friendly with DI environments, and that gives more control to the developer that consumes your API.

If you’re just providing utility functions (like those little packages in npm’s ecosystem), then you could use namespaced functions (but be aware that PHP still doesn’t have function autoloading, meaning that Composer can’t lazy-load your library like it does with PSR-0/4)

More Related Contents:

  1. How to get static data member from php object instance? [closed]
  2. What’s the name of this in PHP? [duplicate]
  3. How should a model be structured in MVC? [closed]
  4. Creating the Singleton design pattern in PHP5
  5. Is it possible to define a class property value dynamically in PHP?
  6. simple explanation PHP OOP vs Procedural?
  7. Can I include code into a PHP class?
  8. PHP class instantiation. To use or not to use the parentheses? [closed]
  9. Why is require_once so bad to use?
  10. How can I get the classname from a static call in an extended PHP class?
  11. How to clear APC cache entries?
  12. Why is overriding method parameters a violation of strict standards in PHP?
  13. Are objects in PHP assigned by value or reference?
  14. What is the difference between self::$bar and static::$bar in PHP?
  15. Getting HTTP code in PHP using curl
  16. Fatal error: Using $this when not in object context
  17. Which is Faster and better, Switch Case or if else if?
  18. What is the fastest XML parser in PHP?
  19. Design Patterns: How to create database object/connection only when needed?
  20. How to access Magento user’s session from outside Magento?
  21. Is PHP’s count() function O(1) or O(n) for arrays?
  22. Advantages / Disadvantages of pconnect option in CodeIgniter
  23. How does array_diff work?
  24. Undefined index: file
  25. Call method by string?
  26. PHP include(): File size & performance
  27. PHP image resize on the fly vs storing resized images
  28. How to create a fluent query interface?
  29. Safe alternatives to PHP Globals (Good Coding Practices)
  30. Which is faster in PHP, $array[] = $value or array_push($array, $value)?

Leave a Comment