PHP image resize on the fly vs storing resized images

by

This is absolutely incomparable matters.

Resizing images on the fly, in fact, is like running a DoS attack on your own server. Resize of one usual image require more CPU and RAM than serving one usual request to php script. That’s ALREADY a huge impact on performance. Yet a usual thumbnail being shown not alone, but in numbers. So, while showing only one gallery page you are creating dozens of heavy load processes, increasing server load by a factor of ten or more.

Quick and dirty test to prove my words:
Let’s try to resize relatively small, 1,3 megapixel image

$ /usr/bin/time --format="%MK mem %Es CPU time" /usr/bin/convert angry_birds_1280x800.jpg -resize 100x100 thumb.jpg
10324K mem 0:00.10s CPU time

It took us 0,1s, so, showing 10 image previews will eat up a whole second of your CPU time. While properly written PHP gallery page will take around 0,01s. So, with your resize on the fly you are increasing the server load by a factor of 100.

Same with memory. Each resize process will eat no less than 10M of memory (to resize a 100k image file!) with a total sum of 100M. While usual memory limit for the PHP script is merely 8M and it is seldom reached.

That are the real life numbers.

A somewhat funny thing related to this problem:
Exactly the same PHP user who easily throwing away 1000000s of CPU cycles at the same time being incredible jealous to spare 1 or 2! It is not a figure of speech, here is an example on what I am talking about:
A similar question from someone, whose great concern at the same time in as negligible thing as speed difference between Constants, Variables or Variable Arrays. And who recently run into allowed memory size exhausted problem, as though such a disaster was not enough.

There are TONS of questions and answers on this site, debating nanosecond speed difference of whatever operations, answered with inexhaustible dignity, running tests of millions of iterations to show absolutely negligible difference between one-shot operations of several CPU cycles each.

And at the same time there are questions like this – regarding huge, incomparable difference in terms of performance between two approaches, which looks merely equal to the author.

That’s the problem with average PHP user and this site.
The former just have no measure to tell real things from microscopic ones.
Yet the latter have no mechanism for sanity check for the questions – every one answered with equal enthusiasm, even if two questions contradicts with each other (and both with common sense).

More Related Contents:

  1. List of Big-O for PHP functions
  2. How can I measure the speed of code written in PHP? [closed]
  3. Performance of foreach, array_map with lambda and array_map with static function
  4. Speed difference in using inline strings vs concatenation in php5?
  5. Opening/closing tags & performance?
  6. Why is require_once so bad to use?
  7. what is faster: in_array or isset? [closed]
  8. What is the best way to read last lines (i.e. “tail”) from a file using PHP?
  9. Profiling PHP code
  10. How to clear APC cache entries?
  11. What’s quicker and better to determine if an array key exists in PHP?
  12. Getting HTTP code in PHP using curl
  13. Setup HTTP expires headers using PHP and Apache
  14. Resize images in PHP without using third-party libraries?
  15. Will enabling XDebug on a production server make PHP slower?
  16. Efficiently pick n random elements from PHP array (without shuffle)
  17. What is the fastest XML parser in PHP?
  18. generating a screenshot of a website using jquery
  19. FOR loop performance in PHP
  20. What’s the performance cost of “include” in PHP?
  21. Why is calling a function (such as strlen, count etc) on a referenced value so slow?
  22. Performance of static methods vs. functions
  23. for loop vs while loop vs foreach loop PHP
  24. SQL & PHP – Which is faster mysql_num_rows() or ‘select count()’?
  25. MySQL Stored Procedure vs. complex query
  26. MySQL Query IN() Clause Slow on Indexed Column
  27. PHP include(): File size & performance
  28. session_start() takes VERY LONG TIME
  29. Safe alternatives to PHP Globals (Good Coding Practices)
  30. Which is faster in PHP, $array[] = $value or array_push($array, $value)?

Leave a Comment