Should I use Java’s String.format() if performance is important?

by

I took hhafez code and added a memory test:

private static void test() {
    Runtime runtime = Runtime.getRuntime();
    long memory;
    ...
    memory = runtime.freeMemory();
    // for loop code
    memory = memory-runtime.freeMemory();

I run this separately for each approach, the ‘+’ operator, String.format and StringBuilder (calling toString()), so the memory used will not be affected by other approaches.
I added more concatenations, making the string as “Blah” + i + “Blah”+ i +”Blah” + i + “Blah”.

The result are as follow (average of 5 runs each):
Approach       Time(ms)  Memory allocated (long)
‘+’ operator     747           320,504
String.format  16484       373,312
StringBuilder  769           57,344

We can see that String ‘+’ and StringBuilder are practically identical time-wise, but StringBuilder is much more efficient in memory use.
This is very important when we have many log calls (or any other statements involving strings) in a time interval short enough so the Garbage Collector won’t get to clean the many string instances resulting of the ‘+’ operator.

And a note, BTW, don’t forget to check the logging level before constructing the message.

Conclusions:

  1. I’ll keep on using StringBuilder.
  2. I have too much time or too little life.

More Related Contents:

  1. Fastest way to strip all non-printable characters from a Java String
  2. StringBuilder vs String concatenation in toString() in Java
  3. When to use StringBuilder in Java [duplicate]
  4. How to format strings in Java
  5. Fastest way to iterate over all the chars in a String
  6. Which loop has better performance? Why?
  7. Performance penalty of String.intern()
  8. Garbage collection behaviour for String.intern()
  9. Why does appending “” to a String save memory?
  10. Which of these pieces of code is faster in Java?
  11. How to center a string using String.format?
  12. Java split String performances
  13. ‘ … != null’ or ‘null != ….’ best performance?
  14. Is there a memory-efficient replacement of java.lang.String?
  15. How can I get the size of an array, a Collection, or a String in Java?
  16. Java String – See if a string contains only numbers and not letters
  17. Java compile speed vs Scala compile speed
  18. How to insert Space after every Character of an existing String in Java?
  19. Why is reflection slow?
  20. what is Ljava.lang.String;@
  21. What is the most efficient way to convert an int to a String?
  22. Performance of WebView in JavaFX
  23. String.replaceAll is considerably slower than doing the job yourself
  24. Remove all occurrences of \ from string
  25. Is there a difference between String concat and the + operator in Java? [duplicate]
  26. What GC parameters is a JVM running with?
  27. Java Encode file to Base64 string To match with other encoded string
  28. Java String literal pool and string object
  29. How to convert hex string to float in Java?
  30. Java: Checking equality of arrays (order doesn’t matter)

Leave a Comment