Using ‘try’ vs. ‘if’ in Python

by

You often hear that Python encourages EAFP style (“it’s easier to ask for forgiveness than permission”) over LBYL style (“look before you leap”). To me, it’s a matter of efficiency and readability.

In your example (say that instead of returning a list or an empty string, the function were to return a list or None), if you expect that 99 % of the time result will actually contain something iterable, I’d use the try/except approach. It will be faster if exceptions really are exceptional. If result is None more than 50 % of the time, then using if is probably better.

To support this with a few measurements:

>>> import timeit
>>> timeit.timeit(setup="a=1;b=1", stmt="a/b") # no error checking
0.06379691968322732
>>> timeit.timeit(setup="a=1;b=1", stmt="try:\n a/b\nexcept ZeroDivisionError:\n pass")
0.0829463709378615
>>> timeit.timeit(setup="a=1;b=0", stmt="try:\n a/b\nexcept ZeroDivisionError:\n pass")
0.5070195056614466
>>> timeit.timeit(setup="a=1;b=1", stmt="if b!=0:\n a/b")
0.11940114974277094
>>> timeit.timeit(setup="a=1;b=0", stmt="if b!=0:\n a/b")
0.051202772912802175

So, whereas an if statement always costs you, it’s nearly free to set up a try/except block. But when an Exception actually occurs, the cost is much higher.

Moral:

  • It’s perfectly OK (and “pythonic”) to use try/except for flow control,
  • but it makes sense most when Exceptions are actually exceptional.

From the Python docs:

EAFP

Easier to ask for forgiveness than
permission. This common Python coding
style assumes the existence of valid
keys or attributes and catches
exceptions if the assumption proves
false. This clean and fast style is
characterized by the presence of many
try and except statements. The
technique contrasts with the LBYL
style common to many other languages
such as C.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why is “1000000000000000 in range(1000000000000001)” so fast in Python 3?
  2. How to install pip with Python 3?
  3. Plotting in a non-blocking way with Matplotlib
  4. Deleting multiple elements from a list
  5. Check if a file is not open nor being used by another process
  6. Why do some built-in Python functions only have pass?
  7. What’s the biggest difference between dir() and __dict__ in Python
  8. shuffle string in python
  9. pandas DataFrame output end of csv
  10. Detect in python which keys are pressed
  11. OpenCV: “[ WARN:0] terminating async callback” when attempting to take a picture
  12. How can I convert XML into a Python object?
  13. How to find the last row in a column using openpyxl normal workbook?
  14. Spark add new column to dataframe with value from previous row
  15. Comparing floats in a pandas column
  16. Calling a python script from command line without typing “python” first
  17. Dictionary column in pandas dataframe
  18. How do I set TensorFlow RNN state when state_is_tuple=True?
  19. How do I split a string into several columns in a dataframe with pandas Python?
  20. Pandas: combining header rows of a multiIndex DataFrame
  21. win32gui.SetActiveWindow() ERROR : The specified procedure could not be found
  22. OSError 38 [Errno 38] with multiprocessing
  23. pandas groupby and join lists
  24. Is it possible to not return anything from a function in python?
  25. Flattening a list recursively [duplicate]
  26. the bytes type in python 2.7 and PEP-358
  27. Read lines from one file and write to another file but remove lines that contain certain string
  28. Better way to shuffle two numpy arrays in unison
  29. How would I check a string for a certain letter in Python?
  30. sklearn pipeline – how to apply different transformations on different columns

Leave a Comment