Variable length arrays (VLA) in C and C++

by

Yes your reasoning is correct, that is how these different forms of array declarations and definitions are viewed by C and C++.

As others already stated, VLA with a veritable variable length (non-const) in global scope is difficult to make sense. What would the evaluation order be, e.g if the the length expression would refer to an object of a different compilation unit? C++ doesn’t have VLA, but it has dynamic initialization of objects at file scope. And already this gives you quite a head ache, if you have to rely on evaluation order.

This leaves the small gap for C concerning length expressions that contain a const qualified object, which isn’t allowed. This comes from the fact that such objects are not considered “integer constant expressions” by the C standard. This could perhaps change in future versions, but up to now the C committee didn’t find it necessary to allow for such a thing: there are enum constants that play that role in C. Their only limitation is that they are limited to int in C, it would be nice to also have them size_t.

More Related Contents:

  1. Why aren’t variable-length arrays part of the C++ standard?
  2. Does “int size = 10;” yield a constant expression?
  3. Invalid operands to binary expression while implementing vector [closed]
  4. For loop with an array
  5. Difficulties on atributting a array to another [closed]
  6. C++ Large 2D array (on the heap) crashes the application
  7. can’t extract data from a structure array c++ [closed]
  8. How would I implement Arrays into this code
  9. Initialization of all elements of an array to one default value in C++?
  10. How to return an array from a function?
  11. Does C++ support Variable Length Arrays?
  12. getting size of array from pointer c++
  13. Difference between array type and array allocated with malloc
  14. Can placement new for arrays be used in a portable way?
  15. Are variable length arrays there in c++?
  16. Printing an array in C++?
  17. Comparing arrays for equality in C++
  18. c++ array assignment of multiple values
  19. Common array length macro for C? [duplicate]
  20. How do you initialise a dynamic array in C++?
  21. pointer to array c++
  22. Finding smallest value in an array most efficiently
  23. Can std::begin work with array parameters and if so, how?
  24. How can I make `new[]` default-initialize the array of primitive types?
  25. What am I not understanding about getline+strings?
  26. Braces around string literal in char array declaration valid? (e.g. char s[] = {“Hello World”})
  27. Setting pointer to arbitrary dimension array?
  28. how do arrays work internally in c/c++
  29. Why can’t I initialize a variable-sized array?
  30. How can a char pointer be initialized with a string (Array of characters) but an int pointer not with an array of integer? [duplicate]

Leave a Comment