When to use lambda, when to use Proc.new?

by

Another important but subtle difference between procs created with lambda and procs created with Proc.new is how they handle the return statement:

  • In a lambda-created proc, the return statement returns only from the proc itself
  • In a Proc.new-created proc, the return statement is a little more surprising: it returns control not just from the proc, but also from the method enclosing the proc!

Here’s lambda-created proc’s return in action. It behaves in a way that you probably expect:

def whowouldwin

  mylambda = lambda {return "Freddy"}
  mylambda.call

  # mylambda gets called and returns "Freddy", and execution
  # continues on the next line

  return "Jason"

end


whowouldwin
#=> "Jason"

Now here’s a Proc.new-created proc’s return doing the same thing. You’re about to see one of those cases where Ruby breaks the much-vaunted Principle of Least Surprise:

def whowouldwin2

  myproc = Proc.new {return "Freddy"}
  myproc.call

  # myproc gets called and returns "Freddy", 
  # but also returns control from whowhouldwin2!
  # The line below *never* gets executed.

  return "Jason"

end


whowouldwin2         
#=> "Freddy"

Thanks to this surprising behavior (as well as less typing), I tend to favor using lambda over Proc.new when making procs.

More Related Contents:

  1. Using ‘return’ in a Ruby block
  2. What does to_proc method mean in Ruby?
  3. how to i add objects to an array ? ruby
  4. Converting an array of numbers to characters ruby [closed]
  5. Installed Ruby 1.9.3 with RVM but command line doesn’t show ruby -v
  6. Difference between class variables and class instance variables?
  7. Where and how is the _ (underscore) variable specified?
  8. How can I get source code of a method dynamically and also which file is this method locate in
  9. What are the Ruby Gotchas a newbie should be warned about? [closed]
  10. How to check if a URL is valid
  11. Ruby 1.9 Array.to_s behaves differently?
  12. How do I parse a YAML file in Ruby?
  13. Safe ActiveRecord like query
  14. How to increase stack size for a ruby app. Recursive app getting: Stack level too deep (SystemStackError)
  15. In Ruby, why does Array.new(size, object) create an array consisting of multiple references to the same object?
  16. Avoiding AppleScript through Ruby: rb-appscript or rubyosa?
  17. Best explanation of Ruby blocks? [closed]
  18. How do I create a SHA1 hash in ruby?
  19. Haml: Append class if condition is true in Haml
  20. to_s vs. to_str (and to_i/to_a/to_h vs. to_int/to_ary/to_hash) in Ruby
  21. How can I calculate the day of the week of a date in ruby?
  22. troubles with RVM and OpenSSL
  23. Set time zone offset in Ruby
  24. Print an XML document without the XML header line at the top
  25. What’s the precedence of ruby’s method call
  26. List comprehension in Ruby
  27. Ruby factorial function
  28. Ruby: filter array by regex?
  29. Insert digital signature into existing pdf file
  30. Read and write YAML files without destroying anchors and aliases?

Leave a Comment